delete Modifications to provisions of Part 5 of the 2012 Act
This Order amends the Police Act 1997 (Criminal Records) (Guernsey) Order 2009 to extend provisions of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 to Guernsey, including criminal record certificates, enhanced certificates, DBS formation, and safeguarding vulnerable groups. It adds the Isle of Man Constabulary to participating police forces, revokes certain articles from the 2009 Order, and provides for the timing of when extended provisions come into force in Guernsey subject to registration requirements.
This Order extends existing UK criminal records bureaucracy (DBS, enhanced certificates, safeguarding regimes) to Guernsey with no democratic review by the British Parliament. It represents territorial extension of a compliance-intensive regulatory framework without evidence of corresponding benefit. The Order itself acknowledges this is EU-derived law being retained post-Brexit with no scrutiny, and the gold-plating inherent in the original 2012 Act provisions adds costs without clear justification. Guernsey has its own legislative assembly and should determine its own criminal records regime independent of UK bureaucratic requirements.