← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

keep The Partnership Pension Account Ill-Health Benefits Arrangements uksi-2015-602 · 2015
Summary

Amends the Public Service (Civil Servants and Others) Pensions Regulations 2014 to modify the definition of 'partnership pension account' and inserts new regulations 183 and 184 providing for ill-health benefits and death benefits for persons with partnership pension accounts, with associated new Schedules 3 and 4.

Reason

Britons would be worse off if deleted because these regulations provide essential ill-health and death benefit protections for civil servants with partnership pension accounts. Without these provisions, vulnerable public servants facing serious illness or their surviving dependents would lose statutorily guaranteed benefits. The amendment merely clarifies existing pension arrangements rather than adding regulatory burden, and operates within the context of government employment contracts where such benefits serve legitimate social functions.

delete The Working Tax Credit (Entitlement and Maximum Rate) (Amendment) Regulations 2015 uksi-2015-605 · 2015
Summary

Amends the Working Tax Credit (Entitlement and Maximum Rate) Regulations 2002 to: (1) replace the definition of 'self-employed' requiring trade/profession/vocation be carried on commercially with a view to profit and be 'organised and regular'; (2) insert requirement that person 'is employed or self-employed' for basic element entitlement; (3) define 'work' as including any work undertaken whether as employed, self-employed, or both.

Reason

This regulation perpetuates and expands government control over labor market participation through the tax credit system. The 'organised and regular' requirement for self-employment is an arbitrary standard that arbitrarily excludes legitimate but irregular work arrangements, restricting voluntary exchange. Rather than deleting unnecessary regulations, this amendment adds new compliance burdens and definitional constraints. The entire framework of means-tested tax credits distorts labor market decisions by artificially subsidizing certain types of work over others. If the goal is to help low-income workers, allowing them to keep more of their own earnings through lower taxes would be preferable to this paternalistic system of credits that creates dependency and market distortions.

keep The Registered Pension Schemes (Provision of Information) (Amendment) Regulations 2015 uksi-2015-606 · 2015
Summary

Amends the Registered Pension Schemes (Provision of Information) Regulations 2006 to update reporting requirements for pension schemes, including: revised categories for scheme legal structure and member counts; new information obligations around benefit crystallisation event 5C (relevant unused uncrystallised funds); updated terminology from 'conversion date' to 'first flexi-access date' for flexi-access drawdown funds; new regulation 15ZA requiring scheme administrators to provide specific information to other schemes when transferring dependant's, nominee's, or successor's drawdown funds.

Reason

These amendments provide administrative clarity and reporting consistency for pension scheme administrators fulfilling tax obligations under the lifetime allowance regime. The information requirements facilitate legitimate tax collection and help prevent avoidance. The compliance costs are proportionate to the tax policy objectives and the regulations do not restrict pension product innovation, scheme formation, or market competition. Deletion would create uncertainty in pension administration and increase the risk of tax loss through incomplete reporting.

delete The Social Security Contributions (Limited Liability Partnership) (Amendment) Regulations 2015 uksi-2015-607 · 2015
Summary

Amends the Social Security Contributions (Limited Liability Partnership) Regulations 2014 to clarify that LLP members engaged in profit-making trades/professions are treated as self-employed earners for National Insurance contributions purposes, effective from tax year 2015-16. Creates separate provisions for Great Britain (regulation 2B) and Northern Ireland (regulation 2C).

Reason

This regulation codifies a form of tax arbitrage that distorts the employment relationship. LLP members performing identical work to employees can avoid National Insurance contributions through structural arrangement, creating an uneven playing field that disadvantages ordinary employees and inflates public coffers losses. The 'self-employed' treatment of LLP members for NIC purposes is not a correction of market failure but a government-created preference that increases fiscal distortion and suppresses dynamic labour market adjustments. Such classification rules should be deleted to allow genuine market-based determination of employment status.

keep The Individual Savings Account (Amendment) Regulations 2015 uksi-2015-608 · 2015
Summary

Amends ISA subscription limits for 2015/16 tax year, increasing the standard ISA annual limit from £15,000 to £15,240 and the junior ISA limit from £4,000 to £4,080. Both increases represent approximately 1.6% adjustments.

Reason

While ISAs are a tax intervention, this amendment merely adjusts contribution caps upward to account for inflation. Removing it would revert to the lower 2014-15 limits, restricting Britons' ability to save. The underlying ISA regime would remain unchanged; deleting this would directly harm savers by imposing artificially low caps without reducing any regulatory burden.

delete The Energy Performance of Buildings (England and Wales) (Amendment) Regulations 2015 uksi-2015-609 · 2015
Summary

Amendment Regulations 2015 modifying the Energy Performance of Buildings (England and Wales) Regulations 2012. Key changes include: clarifying responsibilities for energy performance statements; limiting air-conditioning inspections to 'accessible parts' only; restricting improvement recommendations to 'cost-effective' measures only; adjusting register data fees (£1.27/£11.66); redefining data packs from 'small/medium/large' to 'regular/large' categories; and modifying bulk data access fees (1p→2p per unit for regular packs, 10p→4p). Primarily technical amendments to definitions, scope limitations, and fee structures.

Reason

While modest tweaks are made (narrowing inspections to accessible parts, limiting recommendations to cost-effective improvements), the regulation maintains a costly bureaucratic apparatus for energy performance certificates that adds friction to property transactions. The original retained EU framework imposes compliance costs on every property sale or rental, creating administrative burdens without clear evidence of improved energy outcomes. Fee adjustments and data pack redefinitions are internal reorganisation that does nothing to reduce the underlying compliance burden on property owners and developers.

delete The Firearms (Variation of Fees) Order 2015 uksi-2015-611 · 2015
Summary

This Order amends fees for firearm certificates, shot gun certificates, and firearms dealer registration under the Firearms Act 1968 and Firearms (Amendment) Act 1988. It substantially increases certificate fees (firearm certificates rise from £50 to £88, shot gun certificates from £40 to £62) and dealer registration fees (from £150 to £200), while adjusting various other associated fees.

Reason

These fee increases impose additional costs on lawful firearm and shot gun certificate holders without demonstrated justification. The increases appear to be revenue extraction rather than cost-reflective pricing. Higher fees on legal activities do not improve public safety — they merely burden legal gun owners while having no effect on criminal acquisition. The Order creates unnecessary compliance costs and represents a stealth tax on a legal activity that serves legitimate purposes including pest control, sport shooting, and collection. No evidence is provided that the fee increases correspond to improved administrative services or enhanced public safety outcomes.

keep Revocations uksi-2015-613 · 2015
Summary

These Regulations revoke specific regulations relating to mink and coypus in England, effective 6th April 2015. As a revocation instrument, this regulation removes existing regulatory controls rather than imposing new ones.

Reason

This regulation is itself a deregulatory measure that removes regulatory burden by revoking prior Mink and Coypus controls. Britons are worse off if this is deleted because it would reinstate those regulations, reintroducing compliance costs and restrictions on the fur industry and wildlife management with no demonstrated market failure justification. The revocation correctly identified these regulations as unnecessary burdens.

keep The Energy Act 2013 (Commencement No. 2) Order 2015 uksi-2015-614 · 2015
Summary

Commencement order bringing Section 150 of the Energy Act 2013 (smoke and carbon monoxide alarm requirements in residential properties) into force. Section 150 imposes obligations on landlords to install and maintain smoke and carbon monoxide alarms in private rented sector properties.

Reason

This regulation addresses genuine externalities and market failures in the private rental sector. Without it, tenants face invisible risks that landlords have no financial incentive to mitigate. Carbon monoxide poisoning is fatal and fires spread to neighboring properties — these are not merely private choices. The regulation is low-cost (alarms are inexpensive), well-targeted, and the safety benefits are well-documented. Deletion would result in preventable deaths and property damage that affects more than just the occupant.

keep The Market Value of Shares, Securities and Strips Regulations 2015 uksi-2015-616 · 2015
Summary

These Regulations establish standardized methods for determining the market value of shares, securities, and strips for UK tax purposes. They apply to shares/securities on the official UK list (using Stock Exchange Daily Official List closing prices with a specific calculation formula) and foreign-listed securities (using foreign exchange lists with priority rules for major exchanges). The regulations include a 'special circumstances' exception for listed shares and provide detailed rules for determining values on days when exchanges are open or closed.

Reason

Without these prescribed valuation rules, determining market value for tax purposes would become uncertain, requiring expensive professional valuations and generating costly disputes. The methodology is market-referencing rather than government-prescribed pricing, and provides essential certainty for capital gains tax and income tax calculations on securities. Deletion would harm ordinary investors and businesses through increased compliance costs and litigation risk, with no corresponding economic benefit.

delete Special provision for the calculation of retained rates income for the financial years beginning on 1st April 2013, 1st April 2014, 1st April 2015, 1st April 2016 and 1st April 2017 uksi-2015-617 · 2015
Summary

Amends the Non-Domestic Rating (Levy and Safety Net) Regulations 2013 to modify business rates retention calculations. Key changes include: increasing instalment payments from 10 to 12 per year; adjusting percentages for first four instalments (9%) and subsequent instalments (8%); inserting new Schedule 1A with disregard provisions for designated areas; and modifying the definition of 'relevant year'. These regulations govern how local authorities retain and pay business rates income under the levy and safety net mechanism.

Reason

This amendment adds administrative complexity through new Schedule 1A disregard mechanisms and increased instalment requirements (12 vs 10) without corresponding benefits. The levy and safety net system itself is a Government intervention that distorts local authority incentives regarding business development — authorities face reduced incentive to attract new business if incremental rates income is subject to levy, while the safety net creates moral hazard. This 2015 amendment further entrenches this flawed system by adding technical provisions that increase compliance costs for billing authorities with no clear justification for the additional complexity.

delete BIRDS TREATED AS REGISTERED BY VIRTUE OF REGISTRATION IN THE CITES REGISTER uksi-2015-618 · 2015
Summary

These Regulations require registration of birds listed in Schedule 4 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, mandate ringing with official rings obtained from the Secretary of State (or CITES marking as alternative), and maintain a government register specifying where each registered bird is kept. They impose notification requirements when birds are moved, impose strict time limits on temporary absences from registered addresses (3 weeks for intermittent absences, 6 weeks for continuous absences), and specify circumstances under which registration ceases including death, escape, sale, export, or ring removal.

Reason

This regulation creates a bureaucratic registry monopoly with no demonstrated conservation benefit beyond what market mechanisms or voluntary certification could achieve. The 3-week/6-week time limits on temporary absences from registered addresses are arbitrary constraints that serve no clear purpose and restrict legitimate use of property. The mandatory ringing requirement and government-controlled ring supply system adds compliance costs without evidence of addressing any market failure. These requirements likely suppress the captive bird trade and reduce supply of birds to legitimate keepers, while the registration system itself creates barriers to entry for small-scale keepers. The regulation extends government control over private property (captive birds) with inadequate justification.

delete The Local Government (Prohibition of Charges at Household Waste Recycling Centres) (England) Order 2015 uksi-2015-619 · 2015
Summary

This Order prohibits local authorities in England from charging persons resident in their area to enter, exit from, or deposit household waste at household waste recycling centres. It achieves this by disapplying section 93(1) of the Local Government Act 2003 (which permits charging for services) specifically for these centres. The Order came into force on 6 April 2015 but the prohibition was deferred until 1 April 2020 for authorities already charging at that time.

Reason

Price mechanisms are essential for efficient resource allocation — charging for waste disposal encourages waste reduction and proper sorting. This Order removes the discretion of locally-accountable authorities to determine appropriate funding models for their services, forcing them to cross-subsidise recycling centres from general council tax revenues or reduce other services. The 5-year transition period itself acknowledges significant disruption was anticipated. While recycling access has positive externalities, targeted subsidies would achieve environmental goals without suppressing price signals and restricting local democratic governance. Removing charges shifts costs to non-users who may not use recycling centres, creating an inequitable cross-subsidy.

keep FORMS PRESCRIBED FOR THE PURPOSES OF PART I OF THE HOUSING ACT 1988 uksi-2015-620 · 2015
Summary

These Regulations prescribe standardized forms for notices and applications under Part I of the Housing Act 1988 relating to assured tenancies and agricultural occupancies in England. They cover procedures including notices under sections 6, 8, 13, and 21, tribunal applications, and various notices regarding rent proposals, possession proceedings, and tenancy conversions between assured and assured shorthold tenancies.

Reason

While procedural form requirements may seem bureaucratic, this regulation serves essential legal functions that protect both landlords and tenants. Without standardized forms, defective notices would trigger costly litigation and possession proceedings could fail on technicalities, causing harm to all parties. The forms provide legal certainty in housing transactions and tribunal referrals. Deletion would create lacunae in housing law administration rather than freeing the market.

delete Revocations uksi-2015-621 · 2015
Summary

The National Minimum Wage Regulations 2015 implement the statutory national minimum wage framework under the National Minimum Wage Act 1998. They define hourly rates for different worker categories (aged 18-20, under 18, apprentices), establish calculation methodologies for different work types (salaried hours, time work, output work, unmeasured work), specify what counts as remuneration and allowable deductions, and provide complex rules for determining hours worked. The regulations set the national living wage rate at £12.21 and establish tiered minimum rates based on age and apprenticeship status.

Reason

Minimum wage laws are price controls that distort labor markets by preventing mutually beneficial employment arrangements where worker productivity is below the mandated rate. These regulations create substantial compliance burdens for small businesses while the complex calculation rules for different work categories (salaried hours, time work, output work, unmeasured work) encourage legal arbitrage rather than productive activity. The tiered age-based rates particularly harm young workers by pricing them out of entry-level positions, reducing apprenticeship opportunities and on-the-job training that would otherwise build human capital. As Friedman recognized, minimum wages reduce employment for the lowest-skilled workers they are intended to help, while Hayek's price theory demonstrates that artificial price floors prevent market-clearing wages, creating unemployment and reducing economic coordination.