delete The Petroleum Licensing (Exploration and Production) (Landward Areas) (Amendment) (England and Wales) Regulations 2016
These 2016 Regulations amend the 2014 Petroleum Licensing regulations to prohibit 'Relevant Hydraulic Fracturing' (shale fracturing involving >1,000m³ fluid at any stage or >10,000m³ total) in 'Protected Areas', which include protected groundwater source areas, European sites (Natura 2000), Sites of Special Scientific Interest, and Ramsar wetlands. The regulation grants absolute prohibition rather than requiring enhanced safeguards or risk-based conditions.
Blanket prohibition in Protected Areas prevents any consideration of site-specific conditions, technological improvements, or enhanced safeguards that could permit safe extraction. The arbitrary fluid volume thresholds (1,000m³/10,000m³) lack empirical basis. This creates perverse incentives to fragment operations to stay below thresholds rather than invest in safer technology. Protected Area designations themselves reflect regulatory overreach—SSSIs and European sites represent government seizure of property rights without compensation. The regulation discourages investment in frontier energy resources, harms Britain's competitiveness in energy production, and treats all Protected Areas as equally fragile despite vast differences in actual risk profiles. Alternative risk-based regulatory frameworks could achieve environmental protection more efficiently without outright prohibition.