← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

keep The Safeguarding and Clergy Discipline Measure 2016 (Commencement No. 2) Order 2016 uksi-2016-938 · 2016
Summary

A Church of England commencement order that brings into force sections 5 and 6 of the Safeguarding and Clergy Discipline Measure 2016 on 1st October 2016. This is a procedural instrument that activates specific provisions of the parent Measure regarding clergy discipline procedures.

Reason

This is a procedural commencement order with no regulatory burden - it merely activates existing provisions. The underlying safeguarding objectives (protecting vulnerable individuals from harm) represent legitimate public interest goals that cannot be achieved through market mechanisms alone. Deletion would leave vulnerable people less protected without reducing any economic cost or market distortion.

keep The Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade (Amendment) Regulations 2016 uksi-2016-940 · 2016
Summary

Amends the Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade Regulations 2012 by reducing a fee from £31 to £9.60 in regulation 5A and extending the first reporting deadline to 20th February 2022 in regulation 13.

Reason

This amendment reduces a regulatory fee from £31 to £9.60, lowering compliance costs for timber operators. Deleting it would restore the higher fee, making Britons worse off. While the underlying 2012 regulatory regime imposes compliance costs, this specific amendment provides tangible fee relief and extended deadlines that benefit regulated businesses.

delete The Local Justice Areas Order 2016 uksi-2016-941 · 2016
Summary

This Order reorganizes local justice areas in England and Wales by consolidating multiple existing areas into new, larger ones (e.g., Bristol, North Avon, and Somerset become 'Avon and Somerset'; the various Surrey areas become single 'Surrey'). It comes into force October 2016 for Parts 1 and 2, with full implementation April 2017. The Schedule amends the Local Justice Areas Order 2005 to reflect the new boundaries and names.

Reason

This is an administrative boundary reorganization that imposes no regulatory burden on businesses but offers no meaningful contribution to economic freedom or competitiveness. Deletion merely preserves the previous patchwork of 40+ separate justice areas, which may actually better serve local access to justice. The consolidation provides marginal administrative efficiencies for the court system but these are not substantial enough to justify retaining a regulation that overrides local administrative boundaries established under prior orders.

keep INSTALLATION uksi-2016-942 · 2016
Summary

The Offshore Installations (Safety Zones) (No. 4) Order 2016 establishes a 500-meter safety zone around a specific offshore installation identified by World Geodetic System 1984 coordinates, pursuant to section 21(7) of the Petroleum Act 1987. The Order prohibits unauthorized vessels from entering the zone without permission, with penalties for breach.

Reason

Safety zones around offshore oil and gas installations prevent collisions that could cause catastrophic loss of life, environmental disasters, and economic disruption from spills or explosions. These are genuine negative externalities that the market cannot adequately self-regulate given the tragedy-of-commons dynamics of crowded maritime lanes. Removing this protection would leave Britons significantly worse off from increased risk of major accidents. This is not EU-derived gold-plating but a targeted UK safety measure under domestic petroleum legislation.

delete The Town and Country Planning (Section 62A Applications) (Amendment) Regulations 2016 uksi-2016-944 · 2016
Summary

These Regulations amend the Town and Country Planning (Section 62A Applications) Order 2013 and the Miscellaneous Provisions Regulations 2013. They introduce definitions of 'major' and 'non-major' development, modify design and access statement requirements, substitute new publicity requirements for relevant applications, establish time periods for decisions (8 weeks for non-major development), and add a review mechanism. The regulations govern procedures for Section 62A applications (direct applications to Secretary of State for major or non-major development where local planning authorities may be designated).

Reason

These regulations compound Britain's planning permission regime, which is already among the most restrictive in the developed world. The arbitrary thresholds defining major development (10+ houses, 1000+ sqm floor space, 1+ hectare sites) and the mandatory publicity requirements (site display, newspaper notices, 21-day periods) add cost and delay without demonstrated benefit. Design and access statement requirements impose additional bureaucratic burden. The 8-week decision period for non-major development codifies delays that drive developers away. Such procedural complexity contributes to the housing crisis by raising costs and uncertainty for development. These regulations should be deleted as part of a broader liberalisation of the planning system.

delete The Local Government Pension Scheme (Management and Investment of Funds) Regulations 2016 uksi-2016-946 · 2016
Summary

These Regulations govern the management and investment of Local Government Pension Scheme funds by administering authorities in England and Wales. They require authorities to formulate investment strategies with proper advice, restrict borrowing to temporary 90-day loans for specific purposes, hold fund money in separate deposit-taker accounts, limit investments in connected entities to 5%, appoint investment managers only after taking proper advice, and allow Secretary of State intervention for non-compliance. The Regulations also include amendments to the 2013 Regulations and transitional provisions.

Reason

The regulation imposes extensive bureaucratic controls on pension fund management that limit returns for beneficiaries. The mandatory investment strategy requirements with Secretary of State guidance, the 5% cap on investments in connected entities, the restriction on borrowing even for legitimate temporary purposes, and the government override powers in regulation 8 all constrain effective fund management. These public pension funds are already subject to fiduciary duties and actuarial oversight under the 2013 Regulations; additional layer-upon-layer of prescriptive requirements drives unnecessary compliance costs, discourages innovation in investment approaches, and reduces the flexibility needed to maximize returns for scheme members and taxpayers.

keep The Immigration (Variation of Leave) Order 2016 uksi-2016-948 · 2016
Summary

The Immigration (Variation of Leave) Order 2016 automatically extends leave for overseas domestic workers who have been identified by a competent authority as potential victims of modern slavery. It ensures their leave cannot expire during the pendency of a conclusive determination, extending it until 28 days after the competent authority sends written notice of its decision. The Order implements the UK's obligations under the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings.

Reason

While this regulation restricts automatic deportation of individuals whose leave would otherwise expire, the population affected is narrow and extremely vulnerable. These are overseas domestic workers with reasonable grounds to believe they are victims of trafficking or modern slavery — a category involving exploitation, coercion, and serious harm. Deleting this regulation would mean potential trafficking victims could be removed before a conclusive determination, effectively enabling re-trafficking and denying access to justice. The Order does not regulate commerce, trade, housing, finance, or healthcare markets. It is not EU-derived gold-plating, nor does it add regulatory burden to businesses. The victims targeted by this regulation are not economic agents but individuals seeking protection from serious crimes, and they represent a very small subset of the immigration system.

delete The Self-build and Custom Housebuilding Regulations 2016 uksi-2016-950 · 2016
Summary

These Regulations implement the Self-build and Custom Housebuilding Act 2015 by establishing a local authority register for persons seeking serviced plots for self-build housing. They set eligibility criteria including age (18+), nationality (British/EEA/Swiss), optional local connection tests, financial resource requirements, and fee payment. The register is divided into Part 1 (meets all criteria) and Part 2 (meets criteria except local connection). They establish application procedures, 28-day determination timelines, grounds for removal, and an exemption process where demand exceeds 20% of land availability.

Reason

These regulations perpetuate a bureaucratically burdensome framework that restricts voluntary exchange in the self-build housing market. The local connection test is protectionist, limiting who may participate in local self-build markets based on arbitrary residency requirements rather than market access. Fee-charging authority creates government revenue extraction without clear value. The 28-day administrative timelines and notification requirements impose compliance costs on local authorities. Most significantly, the register itself—regardless of its exemptions—rests on the premise that government should manage and ration access to self-build housing rather than allowing supply to respond freely to demand. The underlying premise that demand must be tracked and matched against 'land availability' through bureaucratic formulas is fundamentally incompatible with a free housing market. If self-build housing is desired, individuals can pursue it without government-mandated registers, waiting lists, and eligibility tests.

delete The Capital Allowances (Environmentally Beneficial Plant and Machinery) (Amendment) (No. 2) Order 2016 uksi-2016-952 · 2016
Summary

A minor amending Order that updates expiry dates in the Capital Allowances (Environmentally Beneficial Plant and Machinery) Order 2003, extending the validity of the Water Technology Criteria List and Water Technology Product List from June/July 2015 to June/July 2016. Also revokes the earlier 2016 Amendment Order.

Reason

While this is a minor administrative amendment rather than a substantive new regulatory burden, it represents an extension of a tax expenditure that distorts capital allocation. Capital Allowances for 'environmentally beneficial' equipment amounts to government picking technological winners rather than allowing markets to determine efficient investment. If water technology is genuinely beneficial, consumer and industrial demand will reward it without need for targeted tax relief. Keeping such provisions alive, even in minor form, perpetuates reliance on regulatory intervention rather than building a genuinely competitive, low-tax economy where resource allocation is determined by profit and loss rather than Treasury-approved lists.

delete The National Minimum Wage (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations 2016 uksi-2016-953 · 2016
Summary

The National Minimum Wage (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations 2016 amends the National Minimum Wage Regulations 2015 by increasing the various minimum wage rates effective 1st October 2016. The changes include: increasing the main minimum wage rate from £6.70 to £6.95 per hour, the 18-20 year old rate from £5.30 to £5.55, the 16-17 year old rate from £3.87 to £4.00, the apprentice rate from £3.30 to £3.40, and the living accommodation daily rate from £5.35 to £6.00.

Reason

Minimum wage legislation is a government-mandated price floor that distorts the labor market by preventing mutually beneficial employment agreements between workers and employers. Such laws disproportionately harm young, low-skilled, and entry-level workers by pricing them out of employment opportunities. The regulations create unemployment traps and reduce the flexibility that a dynamic economy requires. While the amendment merely adjusts rates within an existing interventionist framework, each iteration reinforces a system that reduces economic freedom and can harm the very workers it claims to protect. Deleting this amendment would signal a move toward allowing market forces to determine wages, consistent with Britain's historic tradition of free trade and economic dynamism.

delete The Town and Country Planning (Section 62A Applications) (Hearings) (Amendment) Rules 2016 uksi-2016-955 · 2016
Summary

These are amendment rules to the Town and Country Planning (Section 62A Applications) (Hearings) Rules 2013, governing procedural requirements for hearings on planning applications made under section 62A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (direct applications to the Planning Inspectorate for major infrastructure). The amendments: (1) add a definition of 'relevant application', (2) replace the uniform 'not less than 2 weeks' notice requirement with a tiered system providing 2 weeks for major development and 5 working days for non-major development, and (3) incorporate definitions of 'major' and 'non-major' development by reference to another statutory instrument.

Reason

These are procedural housekeeping amendments with no substantive policy rationale. The tiered notice periods (2 weeks vs 5 working days) represent minor administrative flexibility rather than genuine regulatory reform. More fundamentally, Section 62A itself is a flawed mechanism that routes certain applications around local planning authorities to the Planning Inspectorate — this patch does nothing to address the underlying planning regime that makes such bypass mechanisms necessary. The regulation perpetuates a system where major developments face lengthy hearings processes, and the cross-references to other regulations (the 2013 Written Representations Regulations) create a tangled web of interdependent rules that could be simplified. The 'minimum amount of notice' framing is also evasive language that obscures the actual timeframes from the public.

delete The Housing and Planning Act 2016 (Commencement No. 3) Regulations 2016 uksi-2016-956 · 2016
Summary

Commencement order bringing into force on 1st October 2016: (1) sections 80-91 of the Housing and Planning Act 2016 concerning rents for high income social tenants, and (2) provisions of Schedule 15 and section 183 relating to the general vesting declaration procedure for land acquisition, limited to exercising powers to prescribe statements and forms in regulations under the Acquisition of Land Act 1981.

Reason

Commencement orders merely activate provisions already enacted by Parliament and add no regulatory layer of their own. However, sections 80-91 implement the 'pay to stay' policy for high-income social tenants, which distorts housing markets by maintaining artificially low rents for certain tenants while others face market rates — this creates perverse incentives that reduce labour mobility and misallocate scarce social housing stock. The policy was never properly tested for efficacy and faced implementation challenges. Additionally, high-income social tenants occupying below-market housing prevents those resources from reaching those genuinely in need, perpetuating the very housing scarcity these regulations claim to address.

keep The Crime and Courts Act 2013 (Commencement No. 15, Transitional and Savings Provisions) Order 2016 uksi-2016-962 · 2016
Summary

This Commencement Order brought into force provisions of the Crime and Courts Act 2013 relating to electronic monitoring of offenders on a pilot basis in specific Midlands local justice areas from 17th October 2016 to 30th June 2018. The Order enabled courts in those areas to impose electronic monitoring requirements as a non-custodial alternative for dealing with offenders under section 44 and Part 4 of Schedule 16, with transitional savings for requirements imposed during the pilot period.

Reason

Electronic monitoring represents a less restrictive alternative to custodial sentencing, enabling courts to supervise non-violent offenders in the community at lower cost to taxpayers and with reduced recidivism compared to imprisonment. Without this regulation, courts in these pilot areas would face a binary choice between expensive custody and unmonitored community release. The pilot's limited duration and geography allowed democratic evaluation before any broader rollout, embodying the regulatory caution that Hayek and Friedman advocated — testing interventions before national imposition.

delete POSTCODE DISTRICTS AND PART-DISTRICTS uksi-2016-963 · 2016
Summary

This Order modifies earlier Welfare Reform Act 2012 Commencement Orders (No. 9, 19, 22, 23, 24) to govern the phased rollout of Universal Credit and related benefits. It establishes administrative machinery for claim dates, designated postcode areas (Parts 1-43 in the Schedule), and modifies 'gateway conditions' requirements for various geographic areas on specific dates between 5th October and 14th December 2016. It also contains extensive amendments to interpretation provisions and incorrect information rules in the base orders.

Reason

This is a labyrinthine instrument that exemplifies regulatory accumulation — layering modifications upon modifications (No. 9, 19, 22, 23, 24 orders referencing each other) creating an opaque framework only navigable by specialists. The 'gateway conditions' requirement it partially removes represents bureaucratic gatekeeping that restricts individual access to benefits based on administrative criteria rather than genuine need. The postcode-based phased rollout, while perhaps operationally necessary, codifies geographic arbitrariness and creates differential treatment based on accident of location. Such instruments, as Mises noted, concentrate administrative power without adequate democratic accountability, and their complexity itself serves to obscure rather than clarify the legal position of benefit claimants.

delete The Allocation of Housing and Homelessness (Eligibility) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2016 uksi-2016-965 · 2016
Summary

Amends the Allocation of Housing and Homelessness (Eligibility) (England) Regulations 2006 to expand housing eligibility to a new Class F (for housing allocations) and Class G (for housing assistance) comprising persons with limited leave to remain on family or private life grounds under Article 8 Human Rights Convention, provided they are not subject to 'no public funds' conditions.

Reason

Extends eligibility for scarce social housing to additional immigration categories without expanding supply, worsening allocation competition for British citizens on existing waiting lists. The regulation addresses symptoms (restricted eligibility) rather than the root cause of Britain's housing crisis: restrictive planning permission regimes. Adding beneficiaries to a fixed pool of social housing directly harms those already waiting. The 2006 regulations themselves reflected EU-derived constraints; post-Brexit regulatory review should question why family and private life considerations from the Human Rights Convention should translate into housing entitlements ahead of settled British residents.