← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete The Armed Forces Act 2016 (Commencement No. 1) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1131 · 2017
Summary

These regulations bring Section 15 of the Armed Forces Act 2016 (concerning war pensions committees and armed/reserve forces compensation schemes) into force on the day after they are made. They are administrative commencement provisions with no substantive regulatory content of their own.

Reason

These are purely procedural commencement regulations that have served their purpose — Section 15 of the Armed Forces Act 2016 is now in force. They have no independent regulatory effect and impose no ongoing burden. The substantive policy questions around armed forces compensation would be addressed through primary legislation, not through these spent commencement regulations. Retaining them on the statute book serves no practical purpose.

delete The Non-Domestic Rating (Renewable Energy Projects) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1132 · 2017
Summary

The Non-Domestic Rating (Renewable Energy Projects) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 amend the 2013 Regulations concerning business rate relief for renewable energy power stations. The amendments modify rateable value calculation formulas for Classes B, C, D, and E renewable energy hereditaments, introduce new transitional provisions for the period 2013-2018, and insert Regulation 19 allowing valuation officers to certify adjusted rateable values where circumstances changed between 31 March 2017 and 1 April 2017. The regulations aim to provide continued rate relief as renewable energy projects transition through revaluation dates.

Reason

These regulations represent government intervention distorting market signals through targeted business rate relief for renewable energy projects. They exemplify the classic Austrian economics problem of 'picking winners' — using fiscal policy to steer investment rather than allowing market discovery. The complex formula adjustments and transitional provisions impose administrative burden on businesses and valuation authorities while perpetuating a distortion that misallocates resources toward politically favoured technologies and away from potentially more efficient alternatives. Removing these reliefs would allow business rates to reflect true property values, enabling more efficient capital allocation.

keep The War Pensions Committees (Amendment) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1133 · 2017
Summary

Amends the War Pensions Committees Regulations 2000 to rename committees from 'War Pensions Committee' to 'Veterans Advisory and Pensions Committee', replace references to 'the Veterans Agency' with 'Veterans UK', expand committee scope to include AFCS (Armed Forces Compensation Scheme) benefit recipients, and add provision for Veterans UK as a designated office for war pensions and AFCS claims.

Reason

This is a benign administrative renaming and modest expansion of coverage. Deleting it would create confusion by reverting to outdated terminology (Veterans Agency) and exclude AFCS recipients from advisory services. The regulation imposes minimal compliance burden while ensuring veterans and AFCS beneficiaries have access to advisory committees. The changes are incremental and administrative rather than restrictive regulatory expansion.

delete The Police Barred List and Police Advisory List Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1135 · 2017
Summary

These Regulations establish the police barred list (for dismissed officers) and advisory list (for officers who left with pending allegations), requiring police forces to report certain dismissals, findings, and events to the College of Policing within 5 working days. They specify what information must be recorded, procedures for removal from lists (including minimum periods of 3-5 years), and publication requirements for certain dismissed officers.

Reason

These Regulations create a centralized employment veto over an entire profession, effectively constituting occupational licensing that restricts former police officers' ability to work in law enforcement or related fields. While public safety concerns are legitimate, background checks and reference verification already serve this purpose without concentrating gatekeeping power in a single body. The minimum barred periods (3-5 years) are arbitrary and can punish individuals for conduct that may not reflect current fitness for employment. The College of Policing faces no competitive pressure to ensure accurate or fair decisions, and there is no meaningful market mechanism for appeal. Such comprehensive labor market restrictions on a specific occupational category should require clearer justification than informational coordination, which forces with existing HR systems could achieve independently.

keep The Digital Economy Act 2017 (Commencement No. 2) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1136 · 2017
Summary

A commencement regulation that brings into force on 22nd November 2017 specific provisions of the Digital Economy Act 2017 relating to the electronic communications code, limited to paragraph 106 of Schedule 3A to the Communications Act 2003 (Lands Tribunal for Scotland procedure rules) and section 4 of the Act in so far as it relates to that paragraph.

Reason

This is a procedural commencement instrument that merely activates specified timing for provisions already enacted by Parliament. It imposes no regulatory burden, creates no new obligations, and does not gold-plate any EU directive. Deleting it would create legislative uncertainty without reducing any regulatory cost or barrier to entry. The underlying policy question of the electronic communications code's merits is separate from this timing mechanism.

keep The Town and Country Planning (Operation Stack) Special Development (Amendment) Order 2017 uksi-2017-1137 · 2017
Summary

Amends the Town and Country Planning (Operation Stack) Special Development Order 2015 by extending the expiration date of temporary planning permissions and associated conditions from 31st December 2017 to 31st December 2019. Operation Stack is the government's temporary arrangement to use road networks as lorry parks during Channel port disruptions.

Reason

This is a targeted, time-limited extension of existing temporary planning permissions for a specific operational emergency measure (Operation Stack). Deleting it would remove the legal basis for handling cross-Channel freight disruptions at Channel ports, leaving no alternative mechanism. The permissions are explicitly temporary (now extended to end of 2019) and don't represent permanent regulatory burden. Without this framework, government would lack lawful authority to manage lorry queuing during port crises, directly harming both freight operators and consumers.

delete The Cultural Test (Television Programmes) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1138 · 2017
Summary

Amends Schedule 1 of the 2013 Cultural Test Regulations by updating the table of countries/international organisations with which the UK has cultural test agreements for television programmes, including new entries for China and updated Command Paper references. Revokes the 2015 Amendment (No. 2) Regulations.

Reason

The Cultural Test regime is a managed-trade instrument that picks winners and losers in the television market based on national origin rather than merit, distorting consumer choice and creating preferential barriers. This 2017 amendment merely updates which foreign governments receive preferential treatment—yet the underlying problem persists: the regime props up politically-favoured productions while suppressing open competition. Such cultural protectionism adds bureaucratic cost, invites rent-seeking, and restricts Britons' freedom to produce and watch content based on quality rather than passport. The 2013 Regulations establishing this system should be repealed wholesale; incremental amendments like this merely refine a fundamentally flawed instrument.

keep The Policing and Crime Act 2017 (Commencement No. 5 and Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1139 · 2017
Summary

Commencement regulations appointing 15th December 2017 and 1st December 2018 as dates for various Policing and Crime Act 2017 provisions to come into force, including police disciplinary proceedings, police barred/advisory lists, powers for civilian staff and volunteers, and abolition of traffic warden office. Also contains transitional provisions preserving prior designations under section 38 of the Police Reform Act 2002.

Reason

This is a procedural commencement regulation that merely activates primary legislation already passed by Parliament. The substantive provisions it brings into force (police disciplinary reforms, civilian staff powers, traffic warden abolition) represent legitimate democratic policy choices. Deleting this would only delay implementation of reforms Parliament has already enacted, without reducing any regulatory burden—the underlying Acts remain in force. There is no identifiable cost to keeping this instrument.

keep Consequential and supplementary amendments uksi-2017-1140 · 2017
Summary

These Regulations establish the governance framework for the Police Federation for England and Wales, a staff association for police officers below superintendent rank. They prescribe the structure of Federation branches, branch councils, branch boards, national council, and national board; membership rules (opt-in with voluntary subscriptions for advice/representation); election procedures and terms of office for elected representatives and Federation officers; an annual conference; equality assessments; and financial management including branch funds, national fund, and trustees. The Federation provides advice and representation in disciplinary proceedings, performance matters, and complaints.

Reason

This is domestic UK legislation establishing governance for a police staff association, not an EU-derived regulation. While one might argue the Federation could exist as a private association, deleting this would create legal uncertainty for approximately 140,000+ police officers regarding their representative body, its funding mechanisms, election procedures, and entitlement to advice/representation in disciplinary and complaint matters. The statutory framework ensures consistent governance and accountability. The costs of deletion (confusion, potential industrial relations disruption in an essential public service) outweigh the regulatory burden.

delete Classes for Severn charging schemes uksi-2017-1141 · 2017
Summary

Amendment to the 2001 Road User Charging regulations that splits vehicle classes into Schedule 1 (general) and Schedule 2 (Severn Bridges-specific), enabling differential charging for the Severn Bridges crossing between England and Wales.

Reason

This amendment perpetuates the Severn Bridges tolling regime, which impede free movement between England and Wales. The regulations merely create administrative vehicle classifications for a bridge crossing rather than addressing genuine externalities like urban congestion. The Severn Bridges Act 1992 establishes the underlying tolling authority; this amendment just adds regulatory complexity for vehicle categorisation that could be simplified or eliminated to reduce burden on drivers crossing between England and Wales.

delete The Ecodesign for Energy-Related Products (Amendment) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1143 · 2017
Summary

Amendment to the Ecodesign for Energy-Related Products Regulations 2010 that adds three new product categories (air heating/cooling products, solid fuel boilers, and solid fuel local space heaters) to the declaration of conformity table, each referencing corresponding EU Commission Regulations implementing ecodesign requirements under the EU Ecodesign Directive.

Reason

Retained EU law implementing verbatim EU Commission regulations without UK-specific review. These ecodesign mandates increase manufacturing compliance costs, restrict available product varieties, and raise upfront prices for consumers—all benefits that could be achieved through voluntary energy efficiency standards or consumer choice. Post-Brexit regulatory independence requires deliberate UK reconsideration of each product category rather than wholesale inheritance of EU mandates that may reflect continental manufacturing preferences rather than British consumer interests.

delete The Credit Unions Act 1979 (Locality Common Bond Conditions) Order 2017 uksi-2017-1144 · 2017
Summary

This Order sets a maximum of 3 million potential members for credit unions organized under a locality-based common bond (as opposed to occupational or associational common bonds), pursuant to section 1B(3)(a) of the Credit Unions Act 1979, effective April 6th 2018.

Reason

This arbitrary cap of 3 million potential members restricts credit unions from achieving economies of scale and serving larger geographic communities if they can do so efficiently. The figure appears to have no economic justification — 3 million is neither sufficient to enable metropolitan-wide credit unions nor necessary to preserve the locality common bond concept. Such caps limit competition in financial services, prevent credit unions from competing with banks on size, and impose an arbitrary government constraint on organizational freedom that serves no clear market failure purpose. Removing this ceiling would allow well-managed credit unions to grow organically while the underlying common bond requirement in the 1979 Act remains sufficient to preserve their mutual character.

delete The Higher Education and Research Act 2017 (Transitory Provisions) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1145 · 2017
Summary

Transitory regulations providing transitional interpretations of the Higher Education and Research Act 2017 during the period 1 January 2018 to 31 July 2019, specifically bridging the gap before section 5 (general ongoing registration conditions) came into force and substituting 'English higher education providers' for 'registered higher education providers' in specified schedules during the transition.

Reason

Entirely obsolete transitory provision whose transitional period (1 Jan 2018 – 31 July 2019) ended over six years ago. It was never substantive regulation—merely a technical bridge to ensure the 2017 Act could function during implementation. No regulatory burden remains to be removed; the provision simply ceased to have any effect when the transitional period concluded.

delete The Higher Education and Research Act 2017 (Commencement No. 2) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1146 · 2017
Summary

Commencement order bringing into force on 1st January 2018 various provisions of the Higher Education and Research Act 2017, including: OfS general duties (s.2), registration conditions (s.3), quality/standards rating (s.25), access and participation plan approvals (s.29), information powers (ss.62-63, 78), regulatory framework (s.75), Secretary of State directions (s.77), and related schedules for designated body designation and transfer schemes. Also commences certain sections partially for specific purposes such as designation of bodies under Schedules 4 and 6.

Reason

This commencement order activates the regulatory apparatus of the Office for Students (OfS), a new quango that adds bureaucratic burden without clear market failure justification. The quality rating systems (s.25), access and participation plan mandates (s.29), and registration conditions create compliance costs that fall disproportionately on smaller providers, entrenching incumbents and discouraging market entry. Section 77's Secretary of State direction power and s.78's information-reqing power increase political control over higher education, contrary to institutional autonomy principles. As a commencement order for an Act that itself expanded regulation rather than liberalised the sector, keeping these provisions in force perpetuates a regulatory framework that distorts incentives, raises barriers to entry for alternative providers, and impedes the dynamism Britain should foster in higher education.

keep The Recovery of Costs (Remand to Youth Detention Accommodation) (Amendment No. 2) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-1147 · 2017
Summary

Amendment to the Recovery of Costs (Remand to Youth Detention Accommodation) Regulations 2013, transferring responsibility for receiving payments, issuing invoices, and recovering debts from the Youth Justice Board for England and Wales to the Secretary of State. Includes transitional provisions allowing dual operation until December 2018.

Reason

This is a technical administrative amendment transferring functions between public bodies (Youth Justice Board to Secretary of State). The underlying cost recovery regime for local authorities remains unchanged. Deletion would create administrative confusion, potential payment errors, and civil recovery difficulties as the 2013 Regulations would reference an entity no longer intended to receive these functions. The regulation imposes no economic burden on businesses, merely clarifies which government body handles youth detention cost payments.