← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete The United Nations and European Union Financial Sanctions (Linking) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-896 · 2017
Summary

Amendment to the United Nations and European Union Financial Sanctions (Linking) Regulations 2017 that updates a cross-reference in the Schedule. It replaces the outdated EU Regulation (EC) No. 329/2007 concerning restrictive measures against North Korea with the current EU Regulation (EU) 2017/1509, aligning the UK's financial sanctions linkage with the recast EU regulation.

Reason

This is a technical housekeeping amendment that merely updates a cross-reference. While the underlying DPRK sanctions regime may serve legitimate security purposes, this amendment provides no independent value—its only effect is to create compliance confusion if deleted. More importantly, the correct course of action is not to maintain zombie references but to force proper democratic review: if the Government believes UK financial sanctions should remain linked to EU DPRK measures post-Brexit, it should enact fresh primary legislation subject to full parliamentary scrutiny, not rely on an inherited EU regulation framework that bypasses parliamentary accountability.

delete Technical specifications uksi-2017-897 · 2017
Summary

The Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulations 2017 implement EU Directive 2014/94/EU, establishing mandatory technical specifications for electric vehicle recharging points (normal power ≤22kW and high power >22kW), hydrogen refuelling points, and shore-side electricity supply installations at ports. They require infrastructure operators to incorporate intelligent metering systems, provide ad-hoc public access to recharging points, make geographic location data publicly available, and comply with enforcement mechanisms including civil penalties up to £300,000 for harbour authorities. The regulations are enforced by the Secretary of State with powers of entry, inspection, and seizure.

Reason

This regulation imposes substantial compliance costs and bureaucratic burdens on infrastructure operators that will deter private investment in alternative fuel infrastructure. Mandatory technical specifications lock in particular standards, preventing the market from discovering more efficient or innovative solutions through competition. The ad-hoc access mandates and data sharing requirements create ongoing operational burdens without clear consumer benefit beyond what contractual arrangements would provide. The extensive enforcement regime with civil penalties up to £300,000 for harbour authorities adds regulatory risk that will discourage market entry. As a retained EU law implemented to satisfy Directive 2014/94/EU, these regulations were never subject to proper democratic scrutiny by Parliament. Post-Brexit Britain should allow the market to develop alternative fuel infrastructure organically, with safety addressed through existing general safety frameworks rather than sector-specific mandates that distort incentives and impede innovation.

keep The Lobsters and Crawfish (Prohibition of Fishing and Landing) (Amendment) (England) Order 2017 uksi-2017-899 · 2017
Summary

This Order amends the Lobsters and Crawfish (Prohibition of Fishing and Landing) Order 2000 to prohibit fishing for and landing berried (egg-carrying) lobsters and crawfish in England. It adds definitions for 'berried' and 'Welsh zone', substitutes references to 'Welsh zone' for 'territorial sea adjacent to Wales', and inserts a new Article 4A prohibiting fishing and landing of berried lobsters/crawfish. It also adds a review mechanism requiring the Secretary of State to review the regulatory provisions periodically.

Reason

This regulation serves a legitimate conservation purpose—protecting breeding stock to ensure long-term sustainability of lobster and crawfish populations. Without such measures, overexploitation could deplete stocks entirely, harming both the marine ecosystem and the fishing industry itself. The regulation is narrowly targeted, does not broadly restrict the fishery, and contains a built-in review mechanism (Article 6) requiring periodic assessment of whether objectives remain appropriate and could be achieved less onerous regulatory means. The targeted nature of this conservation measure distinguishes it from blanket bureaucratic restrictions.

delete Schedule to be substituted for Schedule 1 to the 1998 Order uksi-2017-900 · 2017
Summary

This Order amends the Income-related Benefits (Subsidy to Authorities) Order 1998 to update subsidy calculations for local authorities administering housing benefit and related income-related benefits. Key changes include: inserting Schedule 1ZA for 'right benefit initiative' additional subsidy; substituting Schedule 1 with updated sums; omitting Schedule 1A (fraud and error reduction subsidy); updating the rebate proportion for 2017-18 to 0.739; revising rent limits for England and Wales; adding audit notification requirements for English authorities; and modifying maximum subsidy amounts for temporary accommodation to 90% of January 2011 local housing allowance rates.

Reason

This amendment perpetuates a complex, market-distorting subsidy system for housing benefits that inflates demand without increasing supply, suppresses rent signals through rebate limitations, and creates bureaucratic overhead for local authorities. The 'right benefit initiative' adds another layer of subsidy without addressing root problems. Routine numerical updates and administrative provisions do not justify maintaining this regulatory machinery. The underlying framework should be reconsidered rather than patched with annual amendments.

keep The Social Services and Well-being (Wales) Act 2014 and the Regulation and Inspection of Social Care (Wales) Act 2016 (Consequential Amendments) Order 2017 uksi-2017-901 · 2017
Summary

This Order makes consequential amendments to multiple social security regulations (including Income Support, Jobseeker's Allowance, Housing Benefit, Employment and Support Allowance, and various other benefit schemes) to account for the Social Services and Well-being (Wales) Act 2014. It ensures that Welsh social services provisions under the 2014 Act are properly referenced alongside the Children Act 1989 when calculating eligibility, income disregards, and capital disregards for various welfare benefits.

Reason

Without these amendments, benefits administered under these regulations would fail to account for Welsh social services legislation, creating gaps in coverage for Welsh residents. The deletions would create anomalies where Welsh individuals meeting needs under the 2014 Act would be treated differently from those under equivalent English provisions — causing benefit errors, underpayments, or administrative failures for vulnerable people receiving care. These are not regulatory burdens but technical corrections maintaining benefit system coherence across jurisdictions.

keep The Infected Blood Schemes (Application of Sections 731, 733 and 734 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005) Order 2017 uksi-2017-904 · 2017
Summary

This Order modifies sections 731, 733 and 734 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005 to extend personal injury tax exemptions to payments made under Infected Blood Schemes. It defines 'Infected Blood Scheme' as NHS-established schemes for individuals infected with Hepatitis C or HIV through contaminated blood products, administered by NHS bodies in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland.

Reason

Deleting this regulation would harm victims of a state-caused medical disaster. These individuals were infected with HIV and Hepatitis C through contaminated blood products used by the NHS - a public health system. The tax exemptions ensure compensation payments are not diminished by taxation. Removing this would effectively punish victims for receiving state-provided remedy, while the underlying schemes and suffering would remain. The regulation is narrowly targeted, imposes minimal compliance burden, and addresses a specific injustice arising from NHS activity.

delete The Value Added Tax (Refund of Tax to Museums and Galleries) (Amendment) Order 2017 uksi-2017-905 · 2017
Summary

This Order amends the Value Added Tax (Refund of Tax to Museums and Galleries) Order 2001 by adding multiple museums and galleries to the schedule of institutions eligible for VAT refunds. It adds entries for St Cecilia's Hall (University of Edinburgh), The Hunterian Collections (University of Glasgow), and approximately 30+ additional museums across the UK, with specified effective dates for VAT refund eligibility going back to various dates between 2013-2017.

Reason

This regulation is a subsidy mechanism disguised as tax administration—government picking which cultural institutions deserve preferential tax treatment creates market distortions, distorts competition between museums (those on the list vs. competitors off it), and invites political favoritism in determining eligibility. If museums and galleries provide genuine public value, they should compete through pricing, private donations, or endowments rather than receiving hidden government subsidies via the tax system. Maintaining this list imposes ongoing administrative burden and represents the kind of intervention Adam Smith warned against: government discretion over which institutions merit support. The VAT system should be neutral and apply equally to all organizations without political selection of winners.

delete The Friendly Societies Act 1992 (Modification of Part 2) (Northern Ireland) Order 2017 uksi-2017-906 · 2017
Summary

This Northern Ireland Order modifies the Insolvency (Northern Ireland) Order 1989 as it applies to incorporated friendly societies under the Friendly Societies Act 1992. It restricts insolvency practitioner qualifications for friendly societies to those fully authorized or partially authorized only in relation to companies, and adjusts how references to company authorization apply across multiple articles governing practitioner authorization, court sanction, and information-gathering powers.

Reason

This regulation creates an unnecessary niche restriction limiting insolvency practitioners who can handle friendly society windings to those company-authorized, reducing competition and raising costs without clear evidence that friendly society members would be harmed by broader access. Friendly societies are not inherently more complex or risky than companies requiring such differentiated treatment. The market for insolvency services would self-regulate through reputation and performance concerns. The regulation serves to protect a small category of authorized practitioners from competition rather than protecting consumers.

delete The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts and Personal Medical Services Agreements) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-908 · 2017
Summary

These Regulations amend the National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015 and the National Health Service (Personal Medical Services Agreements) Regulations 2015. They introduce new data recording and extraction requirements for GP contractors covering: the National Diabetes Audit, Quality and Outcomes Framework clinical indicators, alcohol risk reduction, dementia diagnosis, NHS Digital Workforce Census, and overseas visitor information (EHIC/S1 certificates). They also add new contractual requirements for identifying frail patients aged 65+ and including certain detained persons on GP patient lists before release.

Reason

These regulations impose mandatory, uncompensated administrative burdens on GP contractors, requiring them to record, code, and submit data for multiple national audits and surveillance programs without adequate reimbursement for the compliance costs incurred. The cumulative regulatory burden diverts clinical staff time and resources from direct patient care. The Quality and Outcomes Framework indicator data extraction particularly exemplifies regulatory inertia—these indicators were removed from the pay-for-performance scheme yet data collection continues by regulation, demonstrating how such requirements persist independent of their original rationale. The frailty assessment mandate (requiring GP identification and clinical review of patients aged 65+ with moderate-to-severe frailty) inappropriately shifts social care responsibilities onto primary care without corresponding resource transfer. While data collection has legitimate public health purposes, mandating it by regulation on GP contractors without market-based compensation or explicit funding for compliance represents the type of bureaucratic imposition these Regulations were designed to perpetuate rather than reform.

delete The M48 Motorway (Severn Bridge Weight) (Temporary Restriction of Traffic) Order 2017 uksi-2017-911 · 2017
Summary

This Order imposed temporary weight restrictions on the M48 Severn Bridge during a 'period of danger' (18th September 2017 to 17th March 2019), prohibiting vehicles with operating weight exceeding 7.5 tonnes from using the outside lanes. The restriction applied only when indicated by traffic signs and exempted emergency vehicles.

Reason

This regulation is obsolete — its operational period expired on 17th March 2019 (or earlier). The 'period of danger' was a time-limited occurrence now over six years past. Any current weight restrictions on the Severn Bridge would be governed by separate, current instruments. Retaining this creates regulatory clutter with no ongoing effect, while its original justification (a specific danger period) has long since concluded.

delete The Care Quality Commission (Reviews and Performance Assessments) (Amendment) Regulations 2017 (revoked) uksi-2017-914 · 2017
Summary

No regulation content provided

Reason

No regulation text submitted for review. Please provide a statutory instrument or regulation document for analysis.

delete The Criminal Procedure (Amendment No. 4) Rules 2017 uksi-2017-915 · 2017
Summary

These Rules amend the Criminal Procedure Rules 2015 to add identification requirements at pre-trial hearings in both Crown Court (rule 3.13) and magistrates' courts (new rule 3.27). Defendants must provide name, date of birth, and nationality at first hearing, with subsequent verification at later hearings. The Rules implement section 86A of the Courts Act 2003 by specifying stages at which such information must be required, creating a criminal offence for non-compliance with these requirements.

Reason

While court identification procedures may serve legitimate administrative purposes, these Rules create a criminal offence of failing to provide information that the court already possesses from the charging process. The Rules extend punitive power without addressing any market distortion, competitive harm, or supply-side constraint. Procedural court administration should rely on verification, not coercion backed by criminal sanction for mere non-compliance. A free society should minimize creation of new criminal offences through secondary legislation, particularly for requirements that duplicate existing information flows.

keep The Pensions Act 2014 (Commencement No. 11) and the Pension Schemes Act 2015 (Commencement No. 2) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-916 · 2017
Summary

These are commencement regulations that appoint 18th September 2017 as the date on which section 44 of the Pensions Act 2014 and section 38(1) and (4) of the Pension Schemes Act 2015 come into force. They include an exception for certain occupational pension schemes defined in the 1996 Scheme Administration Regulations.

Reason

This is a pure procedural instrument that merely appoints dates for provisions to come into force. It creates no substantive regulatory burden itself. Deleting it would not remove any regulation—it would simply prevent the appointed commencement dates from taking effect, requiring replacement commencement regulations to achieve the same administrative effect. The underlying policy substance of the Acts remains unchanged.

keep The Children and Social Work Act 2017 (Commencement No. 1) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-918 · 2017
Summary

Commencement regulations bringing into force four specific provisions of the Children and Social Work Act 2017 on 31 October 2017: section 8 (care orders permanence provisions), section 9 (adoption duty to regard adopter relationships), section 33 (power to secure proper performance of local authority functions), and section 42 (improvement standards).

Reason

This is a commencement order that merely activates provisions of primary legislation already passed by Parliament. The costs of these child welfare provisions derive from the underlying Act, not from this procedural SI. Unlike EU-derived regulations or gold-plated directives, this instrument has undergone proper democratic scrutiny as part of the Children and Social Work Act 2017. Deleting it would prevent Parliament's enacted will from taking effect, and the regulatory requirements on local authorities (care orders, adoption assessments, performance standards) represent policy choices about child welfare that fall outside the scope of market-deregulation review.

delete The Nuclear Installations (Excepted Matter) Regulations 2017 uksi-2017-920 · 2017
Summary

These regulations prescribe 'excepted matter' thresholds for nuclear installations under the Nuclear Installations Act 1965, defining fissile materials and setting activity limits (alpha ≤3.3 kBq/g, beta/gamma ≤0.74 MBq/g) for uranium substances. They require compliance with IAEA transport regulations (2012 Edition) for consignments outside relevant sites and establish A2-based activity limits per consignment using IAEA methodologies. The Secretary of State must review these provisions every 5 years, assessing objectives, achievement, and alternative less-onerous approaches.

Reason

Retained EU law from the Euratom framework, never properly scrutinized by Parliament post-Brexit. While nuclear safety objectives are legitimate, this regulation imposes prescriptive prescriptive activity limits and complex IAEA compliance requirements that restrict the nuclear industry's competitiveness without proportional safety benefits. The rigid A2 formulas and fixed thresholds prevent operators from demonstrating equivalent safety through alternative risk-based approaches. The 5-year review mechanism confirms these are not dynamic standards but static rules that could be replaced by performance-based guidance, reducing regulatory burden while maintaining safety outcomes for a UK nuclear industry competing globally with less-regulated jurisdictions.