delete The Accreditation of Forensic Service Providers Regulations 2018
These Regulations (2018, effective March 2019) require competent law enforcement authorities to use UKAS-accredited forensic service providers for DNA profiling and fingerprint analysis. They establish a mandatory accreditation regime based on EN ISO/IEC 17025 or equivalency under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement, with special exemptions for certain Ministry of Defence laboratories handling hazardous materials. Results from all forms of accredited providers are deemed equally reliable.
Mandatory accreditation creates an unnecessary barrier to entry in the forensic services market, driving up costs for law enforcement and taxpayers while restricting supply of providers. The UKAS monopoly on accreditation serves to protect incumbent providers rather than ensure genuine quality. This is precisely the type of EU-derived bureaucratic burden that should have been reviewed post-Brexit — the regulation was inherited wholesale without parliamentary scrutiny. Forensic quality can be ensured through market mechanisms: professional liability, reputational consequences, and adversarial testing in court are more effective and less restrictive alternatives than state-mandated accreditation that excludes competent providers who lack the right bureaucratic certification.