← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete The Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (Commission Regulation (EC) No 865/2006) (Amendment) Regulations 2020 uksi-2020-1668 · 2020
Summary

Amendment to EU Regulation 865/2006 implementing CITES provisions in UK law, inserting Chapter 9A (Articles 45a-45b) which establishes criteria for allowing trade in endangered species through non-designated customs offices. The criteria require the person to have been unaware of the designation requirement and not previously have used an authorised non-designated office. The amendment also clarifies how references to customs offices in other articles apply when such authorisation is granted.

Reason

This is retained EU law added with minimal democratic scrutiny via the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. While the provision offers flexibility by permitting non-designated customs offices under certain conditions, it represents precisely the kind of inherited EU bureaucratic mechanism that warrants review. The criteria create a complex exception framework that adds compliance burden and uncertainty for traders. Post-Brexit, the UK should have the opportunity to redesign CITES implementation with proper parliamentary scrutiny rather than inheriting EU-drafted amendments. The underlying substantive regulation (the ban on endangered species trade) should be retained through primary legislation with democratic debate, not kept as unexamined retained EU law.

delete The Organic Production (Organic Indications) (Amendment) (EU Exit) Regulations 2020 uksi-2020-1669 · 2020
Summary

Post-Brexit technical amendment to Council Regulation (EC) No 834/2007 on organic production and labelling. Replaces 'EU'/'non-EU' origin indications with 'UK'/'non-UK' equivalents, mandates UK organic logo requirements, makes origin indications optional for NI-to-GB products and third country imports, and permits private/national logos alongside the official UK logo.

Reason

While this amendment enables post-Brexit organic trade continuity, it perpetuates mandatory origin indication requirements ('UK Agriculture', 'non-UK Agriculture') that add compliance costs and administrative burden without justification. The origin labelling regime restricts supply chain flexibility by effectively penalising mixing of UK and imported organic inputs, yet the indication is already optional for key product categories. A liberalised approach allowing voluntary origin disclosure would better serve both producers and consumers while maintaining information availability.

keep The Northampton Gateway Rail Freight Interchange (Correction) Order 2020 uksi-2020-1670 · 2020
Summary

A technical correction order that amends the Northampton Gateway Rail Freight Interchange Order 2020 by correcting: (1) article 23(1) reference number from 33 to 32, (2) article 34(3)(b) grammar by substituting 'and' with 'land', and (3) plan numbers in Schedule 16 for speed limit plans (Sheets 2 and 4).

Reason

This is a purely technical correction order that fixes typographical errors, clarifies wording, and updates document references in a pre-existing development consent order. There are no new regulatory burdens, restrictions on trade, or economic impediments created. Removing this correction would leave the original errors unfixed, potentially causing implementation confusion and legal uncertainty for the infrastructure project. Such housekeeping amendments are benign and necessary for regulatory clarity.

delete House of Commons Members’ Fund Resolution 2020 uksi-2020-1671 · 2020
Summary

A House of Commons resolution continuing a £2 per month deduction from MPs' salaries to contribute to the House of Commons Members' Fund, a mutual fund for MPs established under the House of Commons Members' Fund Act 2016.

Reason

This is not a regulatory instrument restricting economic activity but rather MPs legislating their own salary deductions for a mutual fund they control. The deduction is trivially small (£24/year) and the Fund itself is a voluntary mutual arrangement among parliamentarians. As a self-imposed parliamentary resolution with no external impact on trade, commerce, or regulatory burden, it falls outside the scope of regulations that impede Britain's economic competitiveness. However, if reviewed as a statutory instrument, it should be deleted as it represents parliamentary self-enrichment with no democratic accountability to the public who fund MPs' salaries.

delete The Heavy Commercial Vehicles in Kent (No. 2) Order 2019 uksi-2019-9780111189467 · 2019
Summary

The Heavy Commercial Vehicles in Kent (No. 2) Order 2019 restricted heavy commercial vehicles on roads in Kent during 'traffic restriction periods' by limiting them to the nearside lane and requiring cross-Channel permits for vehicles traveling to the Channel Tunnel at Folkestone or the Port of Dover. It established a complex regime of exemptions for vehicles on specific roads, with requirements for permits, border documents, and lane restrictions during periods when the related Order 2019 No. 3 restrictions applied.

Reason

This regulation ceased to have effect on 31st December 2020 and is therefore already expired. As a time-limited instrument enacted specifically to manage a temporary situation at the Channel Tunnel and Port of Dover, it has no ongoing legal effect. While the objective of managing freight traffic during border disruptions may have been valid, the regulation imposed significant compliance burdens, lane restrictions on major A-roads, and bureaucratic requirements on hauliers that would have driven up costs and delayed deliveries. The restriction to nearside lanes only created particular safety and congestion concerns on multi-lane carriageways.

keep The Local Government Finance Act 1988 (Non-Domestic Rating Multipliers) (England) Order 2019 uksi-2019-9780111191422 · 2019
Summary

Sets the non-domestic rating multiplier (B) at 288.7 pence per pound for English local authorities for the financial year beginning 1st April 2020, effective upon House of Commons approval before the local government finance report for that year.

Reason

While business rates are themselves a distortion, deleting this Order would create a legal vacuum in the rating system. Without a specified multiplier, there would be no lawful mechanism to calculate non-domestic rates, harming local government funding stability and creating practical chaos for businesses and councils alike. The specified multiplier, though arbitrary, provides the certainty required for business planning and local fiscal function.

keep The Blood Safety and Quality (Amendment) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 uksi-2019-4 · 2019
Summary

The Blood Safety and Quality (Amendment) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 amend the Blood Safety and Quality Regulations 2005 to adapt them for post-Brexit operation. Key changes include: adding a 'quality system' definition; redefining 'third country' differently for Great Britain (any country other than the UK) and Northern Ireland (any country other than NI or an EU member state); designating the Secretary of State as competent authority for Northern Ireland; modifying how EU Directive 2005/62/EC and related directives apply in GB; updating import requirements for blood components from third countries; and creating new powers for appropriate authorities (Secretary of State, Welsh Ministers, Scottish Ministers) to make future regulations on blood safety standards. The regulations maintain separate regimes for Great Britain and Northern Ireland reflecting the EU exit settlement, particularly the Northern Ireland Protocol.

Reason

Blood safety regulations differ from typical regulatory burden cases because: (1) they impose equal compliance costs on all market participants rather than creating competitive distortions; (2) contaminated blood has historically caused catastrophic public health crises (1970s-80s HIV/Hepatitis C scandals) with lasting consequences; (3) public trust in the blood supply is essential for donation willingness; and (4) this is fundamentally a machinery regulation adapting existing rules to the Brexit settlement rather than new regulatory expansion. While the quality system requirements are prescriptive, the risk of substandard blood products causing widespread harm substantially outweighs compliance costs. The GB/NI division reflects the Protocol's requirements, not regulatory overreach.

keep The Weights and Measures etc. (Miscellaneous) (Amendment) Regulations 2019 uksi-2019-5 · 2019
Summary

Technical amendment Regulations 2019 that update cross-references in UK weights and measures legislation from old EU Directives (e.g., Directive 2000/13/EC) to equivalent EU Regulations (e.g., Regulation 1169/2011 on food information to consumers), correct cross-reference errors in Electrical Equipment (Safety) Regulations 2016, and fix terminology inconsistencies in Non-automatic Weighing Instruments Regulations 2016 and Measuring Instruments Regulations 2016 (e.g., 'placed' to 'made available', 'compliance notice' to 'enforcement notice', correcting regulation number citations).

Reason

These are deregulatory technical corrections that reduce complexity rather than increase regulatory burden. The amendments fix cross-reference errors, update inconsistent terminology, and resolve inconsistencies between the UK and EU versions of retained EU law. Deleting these corrections would leave the underlying regulations in their original, inconsistent and error-ridden state — creating compliance uncertainty, potential legal chaos from contradictory cross-references, and enforcement difficulties. The corrections to 'made available' terminology and enforcement notice references actually improve the clarity and workability of existing regulations without adding new obligations.

keep The Protocol 1 to the EEA Agreement (Amendment) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 uksi-2019-6 · 2019
Summary

These Regulations amend Protocol 1 to the EEA Agreement as it forms part of UK domestic law under the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. They update terminology from 'purposes of the Agreement' to 'purposes of the application of those acts by virtue of the Annexes', substitute 'Contracting Parties' for references to Member States in rights and obligations provisions, and omit obsolete paragraphs concerning EC committees, procedures for adapting EU acts, exchange of information, review and reporting procedures, publication of information, languages, entry into force arrangements, and addressees of community acts. The regulations come into force on exit day and are part of the Brexit statutory instruments preparing domestic law for the post-EU environment.

Reason

This regulation imposes no new regulatory burden and does not restrict economic activity. The amendments remove obsolete EU governance mechanisms (EC committees, procedures for adapting acts, information exchange procedures, reporting requirements) that were EU-specific and would not function post-Brexit anyway. The substitution of 'Contracting Parties' for 'Member States' reflects the UK's new relationship status and ensures legal consistency. Deleting this regulation would create legal uncertainty without any corresponding benefit, as it is essentially a technical cleanup exercise that adapts references to post-Brexit reality rather than imposing new restrictions.

keep The Diocese of Lincoln (Educational Endowments) (Navenby Church of England School) Order 2019 uksi-2019-9 · 2019
Summary

A technical local Order establishing governance arrangements for a historical 1816 educational endowment at Navenby Church of England School, dividing £118,243.31 in trust assets into a School Fund (11/14) and Religious Education Fund (3/14), appointing the Lincoln Diocesan Trust as trustee for the School Fund and the Vicar/Churchwardens of Navenby for the Religious Education Fund, and specifying how income and capital may be applied for educational purposes in the parish.

Reason

This is a specialized trust governance instrument for a historical charitable endowment, not a regulatory burden on commerce or industry. Deletion would leave £118,243.31 in educational trust assets without proper administrative structure, potentially harming the educational beneficiaries the endowment was designed to support. The regulation achieves its limited administrative purpose without imposing costs on third parties or distorting market incentives.

keep The Universal Credit (Transitional Provisions) (SDP Gateway) Amendment Regulations 2019 uksi-2019-10 · 2019
Summary

These Regulations amend the Universal Credit (Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2014 to restrict universal credit claims for persons entitled to severe disability premium (SDP). They create a 'gateway' provision (regulation 4A) preventing single or joint claimants who receive or recently received SDP from claiming universal credit after 16th January 2019, unless they continue to satisfy SDP eligibility conditions. The Regulations also update cross-references in Commencement Orders.

Reason

While typically I favour removing restrictions on individual choice, this regulation protects severely disabled claimants from being prematurely transferred to universal credit before adequate protections exist. The severe disability premium provides essential higher payments for those with significant disabilities who often live alone or with non-carers. Removing this gateway could force vulnerable disabled people onto a different benefit system before appropriate safeguards are in place, potentially causing immediate harm to those least able to adapt to change. The transitional restriction preserves a protection specifically calibrated for this group's needs.

delete The Infrastructure Planning (Water Resources) (England) Order 2019 uksi-2019-12 · 2019
Summary

This Order amends the Planning Act 2008 to: (1) add desalination plants as a new category of nationally significant infrastructure projects (NSIPs), (2) raise thresholds for dams/reservoirs and water transfer facilities to 30 million cubic metres or 80 million litres per day, (3) create Section 28A specifying conditions for desalination plant NSIP status (must be in England, built by water undertakers, exceeding 80 million litres/day), and (4) provide transitional provisions for existing applications. It defines key terms including 'deployable output', 'desalination plant', and 'drought conditions'.

Reason

This Order expands regulatory burden by adding desalination plants as NSIPs, imposing the Planning Inspectorate's costly and time-consuming application process on large water infrastructure. The 80 million litres/day threshold is arbitrary and creates barriers to entry for smaller distributed water solutions. Rather than reducing central planning, this codifies large-scale centralized water infrastructure as the preferred model, crowding out private alternatives. The regime forces desalination projects into a bureaucratic approval process designed for the largest national projects, raising costs and deterring investment in water supply diversity. Transitional provisions merely preserve the old regime for pending applications—they do not address the fundamental flaw that this Order tilts the field toward government-directed巨型 projects over market solutions.

keep The Excise Goods (Holding, Movement and Duty Point) (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 uksi-2019-13 · 2019
Summary

The Excise Goods (Holding, Movement and Duty Point) (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 amend the 2010 Principal Regulations to reflect post-Brexit changes. Key changes include: replacing EU references with UK-specific terminology (substituting 'United Kingdom' for 'EU', 'UK computerised system' for 'computerised system'); updating legal references from EU Council Regulation 2913/92/EEC to Part 1 of the Taxation (Cross-border Trade) Act 2018; removing EU-specific definitions and procedures (omitting references to 'Member State', 'EU requirements', 'accompanying document', etc.); inserting new definitions including 'change of destination message', 'irregularity', and 'EMCS requirements'; and introducing special provisions for Great Britain-Northern Ireland movements under the Northern Ireland Regulations 2020. The regulation also introduces new procedural requirements for electronic administrative documents, cancellation messages, and reports of export/receipt using the UK computerised system.

Reason

This regulation is a necessary Brexit technical amendment that updates retained EU excise law for post-transition operation. While many EU references are being removed, the regulation preserves essential excise duty monitoring mechanisms that prevent duty evasion, ensure proper duty point determination, and enable合法 excise goods movements. Deletion would create regulatory gaps in excise duty collection, disrupt legitimate trade, and remove protections against duty avoidance—outcomes that would harm Exchequer revenue and create competitive disadvantages for compliant businesses. The Northern Ireland provisions reflect genuine constitutional differences requiring separate treatment. Unlike gold-plated directives that added costs without benefits, this regulation adapts existing procedures to a new constitutional reality while maintaining essential protections.

delete The Excise Duties (Miscellaneous Amendments) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 uksi-2019-14 · 2019
Summary

EU Exit regulations that amend excise duty legislation to reflect post-Brexit arrangements. Changes include: updating definitions to reference EU Directive 2003/96/EC; adding Northern Ireland provisions for goods transported via the EU; replacing EU-specific documents (accompanying documents, single administrative documents) with Commissioner-specified requirements; revoking the Travellers' Reliefs (Fuel and Lubricants) Order 1995; and providing transitional provisions for events occurring before IP completion day.

Reason

This regulation was entirely a transitional Brexit adjustment instrument. The substantive amendments have been superseded - IP completion day has passed, making the transitional provisions in regulation 4 spent. The revocation of Travellers' Reliefs eliminates a gold-plated EU relic. The remaining core substance (excise drawback procedures) should be governed by primary regulations subject to proper parliamentary scrutiny, not by Treasury powers to specify requirements in non-statutory notices. This instrument should be deleted as an emergency fix that has served its purpose.

keep The Excise Duties (Miscellaneous Amendments) (EU Exit) (No. 2) Regulations 2019 uksi-2019-15 · 2019
Summary

Post-Brexit statutory instrument amending multiple excise duty regulations to replace EU references with UK equivalents. Removes obsolete EU import provisions, updates definitions (single administrative document, private pleasure craft), modifies spirits strength testing methods to UK-adopted versions, and consolidates denatured alcohol import/export rules under existing UK Excise Goods regulations. Contains transitional provisions for goods in transit on IP completion day.

Reason

This regulation is a necessary post-Brexit cleanup that removes obsolete EU provisions and replaces broken EU references with functional UK equivalents. Deleting it would leave the excise duty framework with non-functional references to EU bodies and import procedures that no longer apply, creating legal uncertainty and enforcement gaps. The regulation is largely deregulatory in nature, removing EU-specific provisions like Community duty suspension arrangements and EU import rules while maintaining the substance of excise controls through UK-adopted methods.