← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

keep The Safety of Sports Grounds (Designation) (Amendment) (England) (No. 4) Order 2020 uksi-2020-1063 · 2020
Summary

Amends Schedule 2 of the Safety of Sports Grounds (Designation) Order 2015 to update the list of designated sports grounds in England. Changes include: updating Plough Lane entry for A.F.C. Wimbledon's new stadium; adding Harrogate Town AFC's Football Stadium; removing entries for The Hive Stadium (Barnet FC, London Bees, London Broncos), Griffin Park (Brentford FC), and Moss Rose Stadium (Macclesfield Town FC).

Reason

This is a purely administrative amendment updating a register to reflect actual stadium occupancy changes (club relocations, mergers, and closures). The underlying Safety of Sports Grounds Act 1975 addresses genuine public safety externalities at large crowd venues where spectators cannot fully assess structural risks. Deleting this amendment would create administrative chaos, with the register showing incorrect/inactive stadium entries. No regulatory burden is imposed on clubs removed from the list—those venues simply no longer host top-tier football requiring designation. The cost of keeping accurate records is trivially low compared to the benefit of maintaining a functioning safety certification regime.

delete The Social Security Contributions (Disregarded Payments) (Coronavirus) (England) Regulations 2020 uksi-2020-1065 · 2020
Summary

These 2020 Regulations disregard 'test and trace support payments' (payments to individuals required to self-isolate due to coronavirus) when calculating earnings for National Insurance Class 1 contributions purposes, and exempt such payments from Class 1A contributions. They were introduced to prevent individuals from facing higher NI contributions on COVID-19 support payments.

Reason

This is a COVID-19 emergency measure rendered obsolete by the passage of time. The pandemic emergency has ended, the Test and Trace Support Payment scheme has concluded, and these regulations serve no ongoing purpose. Keeping them maintains an arbitrary exemption from National Insurance contributions for a category of payments that no longer exists, creating distortion in the contributions system for no valid reason. Regulations born from emergency conditions should be swept away as those conditions expire.

keep ACQUISITION OF LAND AND RIGHTS uksi-2020-1067 · 2020
Summary

This Order authorizes the West Midlands Combined Authority (the Executive) to compulsorily acquire land and rights for the Midland Metro tram extension from Wednesbury to Brierley Hill. It applies modified versions of the Compulsory Purchase Act 1965 and Compulsory Purchase (Vesting Declarations) Act 1981, establishes procedures for temporary use of land during construction and maintenance, sets a 5-year time limit for exercising acquisition powers, requires consent from Network Rail and Canal & River Trust for works affecting their assets, and provides for compensation to affected landowners.

Reason

Britons would be worse off if deleted because this Order enables vital public transport infrastructure that would otherwise lack legal authority. The tram extension provides transportation benefits that markets alone cannot deliver due to coordination problems. While compulsory purchase restricts property rights, the Order includes essential safeguards: mandatory compensation under the 1961 Act, consent requirements from Network Rail and Canal & River Trust protecting critical infrastructure, time limits on powers, and procedural protections. Deleting this regulation would prevent the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill tram extension from proceeding, denying residents improved public transport connections and the associated economic benefits.

delete REVOCATIONS uksi-2020-1068 · 2020
Summary

The Wireless Telegraphy (Licence Charges) Regulations 2020 establish the fee structure for Ofcom-issued wireless telegraphy licenses. They specify fixed and variable sums payable on license issuance, variation, and at prescribed intervals (12, 24, 36, or 60 months), with detailed definitions for coverage areas, frequency bands, population classifications, and congestion levels. The regulations include provisions for charity exemptions (50% reduction), installment payments for large fees (>£100,000), and specific charges for 28 GHz spectrum access licenses. They revoke prior regulations and reference multiple other statutory instruments governing spectrum trading and licensing procedures.

Reason

This regulation imposes arbitrary fees on spectrum usage without evidence that the fee levels reflect actual scarcity or administrative costs. The complex graduated fee structure based on congestion areas, population density, and geographic regions creates significant compliance burdens and barriers to entry for new wireless services. These retained EU-era fees protect incumbent spectrum holders rather than promoting efficient spectrum allocation. Post-Brexit, Britain should adopt a more liberal spectrum pricing regime to enhance the competitiveness of wireless services and encourage innovation, rather than perpetuating a complex bureaucratic fee schedule that has never received proper democratic scrutiny. The detailed technical definitions and region-specific formulas suggest this was EU-derived and likely contains gold-plating that should be eliminated.

keep The Square Kilometre Array Observatory (Immunities and Privileges) Order 2020 uksi-2020-1069 · 2020
Summary

This Order grants immunities, privileges, and tax exemptions to the Square Kilometre Array Observatory (SKA), an international scientific organization established by convention, along with its Director-General, staff, representatives of member states, and experts. It covers immunity from suit and legal process, exemptions from direct taxation, non-domestic rates, customs duties, VAT, and import duties, as well as privileges relating to personal baggage and motor vehicles. The Order applies UK-wide subject to devolution provisions for Scotland.

Reason

While this Order grants substantial tax immunities and privileges that represent a cost to the Exchequer, these are necessary for the UK to fulfill its international commitments as a founding member of the SKA Observatory. The immunities and privileges mirror standard protections under the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations and are essential for international scientific organisations to function. The reciprocal nature of such arrangements benefits UK personnel serving abroad. Deletion would breach the Convention obligations and potentially forfeit the £1.3bn UK investment in the SKA project, while the scientific research from the world's largest radio telescope may yield technological and economic spillovers that justify the fiscal cost of these exemptions.

delete The Health Protection (Coronavirus, International Travel) (England) (Amendment) (No. 16) Regulations 2020 uksi-2020-1070 · 2020
Summary

Amendment to COVID-19 international travel regulations adding a self-isolation exemption in regulation 4(7) and establishing escalating fixed penalties (£1,000-£10,000) for repeat offenses under regulation 6(1)(b), with transitional provisions for pre-existing penalties.

Reason

These pandemic-era emergency regulations exemplify the proliferation of overlapping COVID restrictions that cumulatively restrict freedom of movement and assembly. The escalating penalty structure (£1,000 first offense to £10,000 for fourth+ offenses) criminalizes ordinary conduct (international travel, failure to self-isolate) and punishes repetition heavily without evidence such penalties achieve compliance better than lower, proportional fines. The regulation layers onto existing Self-Isolation Regulations, creating a complex web of compliance obligations. Such emergency measures, enacted without full parliamentary scrutiny under expedited procedures, should be deleted as the pandemic emergency has passed and their continued existence serves only to expand state power over personal liberty without commensurate public benefit.

delete The NHS Counter Fraud Authority (Establishment, Constitution, and Staff and Other Transfer Provisions) (Amendment) Order 2020 uksi-2020-1071 · 2020
Summary

Amendment Order that extends the 'abolition date' of the NHS Counter Fraud Authority from 31st October 2020 to 30th October 2023 — effectively prolonging the body's statutory existence for another three years without any apparent review of its efficacy or necessity.

Reason

This amendment merely perpetuates a government body's existence through惯性rather than merit. It extended the abolition date by three years with no evidence-based justification, public consultation, or sunset review — only administrative inertia. The underlying NHSCFA adds bureaucratic cost to the NHS without addressing the fundamental problem: the NHS's near-monopoly structure itself creates conditions where resources are misallocated and fraud opportunities arise. Deleting this amendment would force proper parliamentary deliberation on whether counter-fraud functions are best delivered through a standalone quango or more efficiently integrated within existing enforcement structures or private mechanisms. Britons would not be worse off — if counter-fraud work has genuine value, it will survive and find alternative institutional homes; if it was bureaucratic waste, this deletion removes it.

keep The Mental Health (Hospital, Guardianship and Treatment) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2020 uksi-2020-1072 · 2020
Summary

Amends the Mental Health (Hospital, Guardianship and Treatment) (England) Regulations 2008 to permit electronic communication and electronic signatures for serving documents related to compulsory mental health admission, guardianship and treatment. Adds email address fields to all relevant forms (A1-A11, G1-G4, H1, H5-H6, M2, T1-T6, CTO1-CTO12). Includes safeguards such as excluding detained patients from electronic-only service and treating orders/notices sent electronically as served at start of next business day. Also removes requirement for private guardians to serve documents by electronic communication and amends nearest relative discharge provisions.

Reason

This amendment merely adds optional electronic communication methods to an existing framework - it does not mandate electronic service or restrict any existing delivery mechanisms. Britons would be worse off without it because mental health practitioners, patients and families would be forced back to slower, costlier postal and courier methods for time-sensitive mental health documents. The regulation reduces administrative friction while maintaining safeguards (detained patients excluded from electronic-only service, business day rule for orders/notices). Deleting it would revert to 2008 rules that are less efficient and impose unnecessary costs on the NHS and families without any countervailing benefit to patient safety.

delete AUTHORISED DEVELOPMENT uksi-2020-1075 · 2020
Summary

This Development Consent Order (DCO) under the Planning Act 2008 authorizes Norfolk County Council to construct and maintain the Great Yarmouth Third River Crossing, a new bridge over the River Yare with associated highways, approaches, control systems, and vessel impact protection. The Order grants extensive powers including compulsory purchase authority, street alteration rights, traffic regulation powers, and exemptions from numerous other statutes including environmental permitting regulations, land drainage byelaws, and various Planning Act provisions. It establishes the legal framework for a major piece of public infrastructure, defining Order limits, maintenance obligations, deviation tolerances, and transfer of benefit provisions.

Reason

This DCO represents the类型的政府主导基础设施审批流程 that creates unnecessary regulatory burden. It grants sweeping compulsory purchase powers, exempts the project from core environmental protections (Environmental Permitting Regulations, Land Drainage Act byelaws, Water Resources Act byelaws), and establishes a bespoke project-specific regulatory regime rather than using existing streamlined processes. The extensive deviation tolerances (3m laterally, 1m vertically for linear works) and the disapplication of standard street works coordination requirements under the 1991 Act reflect a pattern of granting exceptions that undermine the very regulations designed to protect public interest. While infrastructure authorization may be necessary, this Order's approach of blanket exemptions rather than targeted waivers perpetuates regulatory fragmentation and sets a precedent that major projects can opt out of standard protections. A better approach would consolidate needed permissions without the extensive exemption regime that characterizes this Order.

delete The Health Protection (Coronavirus, International Travel) (England) (Amendment) (No. 17) Regulations 2020 uksi-2020-1076 · 2020
Summary

COVID-19 travel regulations that removed Poland, Turkey, and Bonaire/Sint Eustatius/Saba from the quarantine exemption list (travel corridors) effective October 3, 2020. Included a minor textual amendment and transitional provisions for prior arrivals.

Reason

Pandemic-era travel restriction that closed international travel corridors, devastating the travel, aviation, and tourism sectors. These emergency measures have been superseded by subsequent revocations (the principal regulations were repealed in March 2022 as part of the 'Living with COVID' strategy). The regulation imposed substantial economic harm on airlines, holidaymakers, and tourism-dependent businesses with questionable cost-effectiveness given alternatives like testing existed. Now obsolete.

delete The Prison and Young Offender Institution (Coronavirus, etc.) (Amendment) (No. 3) Rules 2020 uksi-2020-1077 · 2020
Summary

COVID-19 emergency amendment rules from October 2020 that modified temporary release provisions for prisoners and young offenders, clarified procedural requirements around coronavirus restricted temporary release, and defined 'transition periods' tied to transmission control periods.

Reason

This regulation is a COVID-19 emergency measure that was explicitly designed for managing prisoner temporary release during the 2020 pandemic. By 2026, the public health emergency has long passed, and the 'transmission control period' framework it references is obsolete. Keeping emergency provisions that were never subject to democratic scrutiny beyond the urgent pandemic context imposes ongoing restrictions without justification. These rules should be deleted as their emergency rationale no longer exists, and maintaining them contributes to regulatory clutter from retained EU laws and emergency legislation that should have been repealed once the crisis ended.

delete The Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (References to Financial Investigators) (Amendment) (England and Wales) Order 2020 uksi-2020-1078 · 2020
Summary

This Order amends the Schedule to the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (References to Financial Investigators) (England and Wales) Order 2015 by adding the Ministry of Justice to the list of qualifying authorities for financial investigators across multiple sections (297A, 303Z1, 303Z2, 336D, 378). Most insertions require the designated person to be at or above Grade 7. The effect is to expand which government bodies can appoint or authorise financial investigators to exercise powers under POCA 2002.

Reason

This amendment expands bureaucratic authority by adding another government body (Ministry of Justice) to the list of agencies authorised to designate financial investigators with asset-freezing and seizure powers. While the amendment is technical in nature, it represents an expansion of state power rather than a reduction. The original POCA 2002 asset forfeiture regime has been criticised for enabling overreach and creating perverse incentives in law enforcement. This Order does not reduce regulatory burden but merely distributes existing powers across more agencies. A bolder reform would be to review the underlying POCA framework itself, not just shuffling which ministries can appoint investigators.

keep The Sentencing (Pre-consolidation Amendments) Act 2020 (Exception) Regulations 2020 uksi-2020-1081 · 2020
Summary

A technical statutory instrument that clarifies the interaction between the Sentencing (Pre-consolidation Amendments) Act 2020 and the Criminal Justice Act 2003 (Surcharge) (Amendment) Order 2020. It is a savings/exception provision ensuring that article 3 of the 2020 Surcharge Order continues to apply despite section 1(3) of the 2020 Act.

Reason

This is a technical legal clarification with no substantive regulatory burden. It merely preserves existing legal treatment of surcharge provisions and does not impose costs on businesses, restrict trade, or create bureaucratic overhead. Deleting it would create legal uncertainty rather than reduce burden, as it simply ensures continuity of existing sentencing surcharge arrangements.

keep The Jobseekers (Back to Work Schemes) Act 2013 (Remedial) Order 2020 uksi-2020-1085 · 2020
Summary

The Jobseekers (Back to Work Schemes) Act 2013 (Remedial) Order 2020 is a remedial statutory instrument that amends the Jobseekers (Back to Work Schemes) Act 2013. It adds sections 1A and 1B to address pending appeals against penalties imposed under the 2011 Regulations and Mandatory Work Activity Scheme Regulations for jobseeker's allowance claimants. The order requires the Secretary of State to disregard certain subsections of section 1 (the punitive provisions) when revising or superseding decisions on these pre-26 March 2013 appeals, effectively providing ameliorating relief to affected claimants by preventing enforcement of provisions that may have been improperly applied.

Reason

This remedial order corrects flaws in the parent Act by protecting claimants from punitive provisions that were potentially improperly applied to pending appeals. Deleting this order would restore the harsher original provisions for vulnerable jobseekers who had appeals pending, causing direct harm to individuals seeking welfare benefits. As a remedial instrument that mitigates harm rather than creating new regulatory burden, its removal would leave claimants worse off.

delete The Immigration (Health Charge) (Amendment) Order 2020 uksi-2020-1086 · 2020
Summary

The Immigration (Health Charge) (Amendment) Order 2020 amends the 2015 Principal Order to increase the immigration health charge from £300 to £470-£624 depending on application type, and creates a new exemption for Tier 2 (General) Migrants with Health and Care Visas. It also adds definitional provisions for terms like 'certificate of sponsorship', 'dependant', 'sponsor', and 'Tier 2 (General) Migrant'.

Reason

This Order functions as a tax on skilled immigration that raises labor costs for businesses seeking to recruit global talent. The increase to £470-£624 creates barriers that make the UK less competitive in attracting skilled workers compared to nations like Canada, Australia, and Singapore that maintain more open immigration policies. The Health and Care Visa exemption creates arbitrary distortions favoring certain sectors over others. Rather than addressing healthcare cost recovery through a simple, transparent mechanism applied universally, this regulatory structure adds complexity while still failing to fully compensate the NHS for healthcare provision. Such charges suppress wage growth, reduce employment opportunities, and distort the labor market—outcomes contrary to Britain's historical role as a beacon of free trade and economic openness.