Summary
The A41 Trunk Road (Westminster) Red Route (No. 2) Experimental Traffic Order 1996 establishes 'red route' stopping and waiting restrictions on the A41 trunk road in Westminster. It prohibits vehicles from stopping during specified restricted hours, with exemptions for disabled persons, loading/unloading (up to 20 minutes), licensed taxis, coaches, doctors' vehicles, solo motorcycles, buses, emergency services, and Royal Mail vehicles. The order suspends the City of Westminster (Waiting and Loading Restriction) Order 1976 for affected areas. Originally framed as 'experimental', it came into force on 4th November 1996.
Reason
This 1996 'experimental' order has now been in force for 30 years with no demonstrated need for permanent retention. Red route restrictions impose substantial compliance costs on businesses through loading/unloading time limits, restrict commercial vehicle operations, and create complex exemption regimes that themselves demonstrate arbitrariness. While traffic management is legitimate, this command-and-control approach could be improved through market mechanisms such as dynamic congestion pricing, which would more efficiently balance traffic flow against economic activity. The 'experimental' justification is absurd after three decades — if the restrictions were needed permanently, they should have been made permanent through proper democratic process. The extensive list of exemptions (doctors, taxis, coaches, motorcycles, disabled persons, Royal Mail, etc.) suggests the underlying prohibition is too blunt and creates perverse incentives.