← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete AUTHORISED DEVELOPMENT uksi-2023-734 · 2023
Summary

Development Consent Order granting planning permission for Longfield Solar Farm, authorizing construction and operation of a solar energy farm with associated grid connection works, substations, and access roads. Grants compulsory purchase powers, street works authority, public rights of way modifications, and various regulatory exemptions. Contains 13 schedules covering authorized works, requirements, street works, access points, and environmental management plans.

Reason

This DCO exemplifies picking winners in energy markets through state-granted planning privileges rather than letting market signals direct investment. The extensive compulsory purchase powers, regulatory disapplications (including environmental permits, land drainage byelaws, and neighbourhood planning provisions), and street alteration authorities benefit a single private entity (Longfield Solar Energy Farm Limited) at the expense of property rights and competitive neutrality. Rather than predictable rules applying equally to all energy infrastructure developers, it creates a bespoke regulatory regime with 13 certified plans and schedules of requirements—exactly the kind of intervention Adam Smith would have warned against. The hidden costs include distorted incentives for energy investment, precedent for political rather than economic allocation of development rights, and the precedent that successful DCO applications require cronyism or regulatory capture rather than market discipline.

keep The Justices’ Allowances (Amendment) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-737 · 2023
Summary

Amends the Justices' Allowances Regulations 2015 governing expense claims by lay justices (volunteer magistrates). Introduces detailed documentation requirements for claims including travelling allowance (distance, engine capacity, expenses), subsistence allowance, and financial loss allowance. Requires written claims with specific particulars, evidence, and declarations. Omits transitional provisions and schedules.

Reason

These are administrative reimbursement procedures for volunteer lay justices, not economic regulation. While documentation requirements exist, they serve the legitimate purpose of preventing fraud with public funds. Deleting this would create unconstrained expense claims without accountability. The amendment actually streamlines the original 2015 rules rather than adding burden.

delete Modifications to Annex IC to Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2016/799 uksi-2023-739 · 2023
Summary

These Regulations amend retained EU Regulation 165/2014 on tachographs (recording devices tracking driver hours in road transport). Key changes include: substituting smart tachograph standards in Article 2(2)(z4); inserting a new Article 3(1za) requiring smart tachograph 1 installation for vehicles registered on or before 20th February 2024; extending various deadlines from August/December 2023 to February 2024; modifying Article 8 to apply recording position requirements to vehicles registered after August 2023 operating in TCA territory; and adding a Schedule modifying Annex IC implementation standards. The Regulations include a review requirement by August 2026.

Reason

This regulation epitomises the problem with retained EU law: inherited wholesale without democratic scrutiny, layering compliance costs onto haulage operators without evidence those costs are proportionate to safety benefits. The repeated deadline extensions (August 2023 to February 2024) themselves demonstrate the original requirements were poorly calibrated. Post-Brexit regulatory independence demands we reconsider whether British drivers and hauliers should operate under EU-derived tachograph mandates or whether market mechanisms and domestic competition law could better address any legitimate safety concerns around driver fatigue.

keep The Victims’ Payments (Amendment) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-742 · 2023
Summary

Technical amendment instrument that corrects errors in the Victims' Payments Regulations 2020, including fixing typos (e.g., 'clam' to 'claim'), correcting cross-references (paragraph/subparagraph references), and clarifying textual provisions. The underlying scheme provides payments to victims of Troubles-related incidents in Northern Ireland.

Reason

These are purely technical corrections that fix errors and improve clarity in the existing Victims' Payments Regulations 2020. Deleting these amendments would leave the principal regulations with cross-reference errors, typos, and textual ambiguities that could cause confusion, inconsistent application, or legal challenges. The amendments impose no new regulatory burden—they merely correct mistakes. The underlying scheme, while a government payment program rather than economic regulation per se, operates as a historical compensation mechanism for Troubles victims where the corrections ensure proper functioning of the scheme's administration.

keep The Fruit and Vegetables Aid Scheme Closure (England) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-743 · 2023
Summary

The Fruit and Vegetables Aid Scheme Closure (England) Regulations 2023 modify retained EU Regulation 1308/2013 to phase out the fruit and vegetables producer aid scheme in England. Key changes include: setting operational programme durations (3-7 years) with at least two objectives from a specified list (production planning, quality improvement, commercial value, promotion, environmental measures, crisis prevention); prohibiting approval of any new operational programme commencing on or after 1 January 2024; and prohibiting amendments extending programmes to end on or after 1 January 2026. The regulation effectively closes the EU-era subsidy scheme post-Brexit.

Reason

This regulation is a deregulatory instrument that closes an EU-era subsidy scheme rather than creating new intervention. Deleting it would reopen the Fruit and Vegetables Aid Scheme, allowing new operational programmes and continued subsidies funded by the public purse. Keeping this closure regulation reduces government expenditure, removes market distortions from subsidised producer organisations, and allows the sector to operate under normal competitive market conditions. The prohibition on new programmes starting after January 2024 and extensions beyond January 2026 ensures orderly wind-down of this interventionist mechanism.

delete The Data Protection (Law Enforcement) (Adequacy) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-744 · 2023
Summary

UK statutory instrument designating Guernsey (Bailiwick of Guernsey) as having an 'adequate level of protection' for personal data under Part 3 of the Data Protection Act 2018, enabling law enforcement data transfers from UK competent authorities to Guernsey authorities subject to the Data Protection (Law Enforcement and Related Matters) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Ordinance 2018.

Reason

Adequacy decisions are inherently protectionist mechanisms that shield jurisdictions from market competition in data protection standards. This regulation prevents UK entities from freely negotiating data arrangements with Guernsey-based entities, instead locking in Guernsey's regulatory framework by government decree. While framed as enabling law enforcement cooperation, it primarily benefits Guernsey's financial services sector by maintaining data transfer pathways that might otherwise require competitive negotiation. Post-Brexit, the UK should not perpetuate the EU-style adequacy framework that constrains regulatory competition. Deletion would allow voluntary market arrangements and force Guernsey to compete on the quality of its protections rather than receiving automatic recognition.

keep The Criminal and Civil Legal Aid (Amendment) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-745 · 2023
Summary

Amendment regulations that expand legal aid access for children (removing financial means test requirements for advice/assistance, legal representation, family help), add provisions for inquest legal help, extend certain provisions to Wales (Education Tribunal), and provide legal representation for High Court matters involving withdrawal/withholding of life-sustaining treatment from children. Includes transitional provisions for applications made before August 2023.

Reason

While these regulations expand government involvement in legal services, the deletions would harm vulnerable populations (children, those facing life-sustaining treatment decisions) who lack the capacity to bear market costs. The regulation primarily addresses equity rather than creating significant market distortions. The expanded access for inquests and Education Tribunal Wales provisions corrects prior fragmentation rather than imposing new burdens.

keep The Public Service Pensions and Judicial Offices Act 2022 (Commencement No. 2) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-746 · 2023
Summary

These Regulations are a commencement order that brings into force provisions of the Public Service Pensions and Judicial Offices Act 2022 relating to judicial pension schemes (Chapter 2), along with interpretative sections 109 and 110 insofar as they apply to that Chapter. The Regulations ensure these provisions become operative the day after they are made.

Reason

This is a procedural commencement instrument that merely activates judicial pension scheme provisions already enacted by Parliament. Without such a order, the underlying statutory rights and obligations would remain inoperative. The judicial pension framework, while representing state provision in a specific sector, does not constitute the broad regulatory burdens this body's mandate addresses (EU-derived laws, gold-plating, financial services overreach, NHS monopoly distortions, or planning restrictions). Deleting or refusing to commence this instrument would create legal uncertainty and operational gaps in the judicial pension system without advancing free-market objectives.

keep The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development etc.) (England) (Amendment) Order 2023 uksi-2023-747 · 2023
Summary

The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development etc.) (England) (Amendment) Order 2023 amends the GPDO 2015 to: (1) modify Class B temporary use rules for caravans/camping with festival exceptions; (2) insert new Class BC creating permitted development rights for temporary recreational campsites (max 60 days/year, 50 pitches) with conditions including toilet facilities, LPA notification, and flood zone prior approval requirements; (3) extend film-making permissions from 9 to 12 months, increase site area from 1.5 to 3 hectares, and increase structure height from 15m to 20m; (4) add Class MA permitting prison fence alterations up to 5.5m without full planning permission; and (5) make various technical amendments to compensation regulations and development management procedures.

Reason

These amendments incrementally liberalise planning controls, expanding permitted development rights that did not previously exist. Britons would be worse off if deleted because: (1) temporary recreational campsite rights under Class BC would be removed, restricting a potential growth sector for rural tourism; (2) film-making would revert to stricter 9-month/1.5ha/15m limits, damaging a valuable industry; (3) prison fence works would again require full planning permission, adding cost and delay to essential security infrastructure. While these changes remain within the state's discretion framework, they represent genuine reductions in regulatory burden that benefit specific sectors and the broader economy.

keep The International Organisations (Tax Exemptions Designation) (Amendment) Order 2023 uksi-2023-748 · 2023
Summary

This is a minor technical amendment to the International Organisations (Tax Exemptions Designation) Order 2023. It corrects two drafting errors: (1) in article 2(1), expanding the reference from paragraph (3)(a) to the broader paragraph (3), and (2) in article 2(2), singularising 'paragraph' to 'paragraphs'. These appear to be consequential corrections following earlier amendments.

Reason

While tax exemptions for international organisations represent government intervention that distorts competition, this amendment corrects an apparent drafting error that would have incorrectly limited the scope of the original Order. Deleting this amendment would leave a malfunctioning regulation in place, producing outcomes contrary to Parliament's stated intent and creating legal uncertainty that harms both the intended beneficiaries and those subject to the rules. Technical corrections that restore legislative intent do not constitute the regulatory burden this agency targets.

keep The Social Security (Contributions) (Amendment No. 4) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-751 · 2023
Summary

Amends the Social Security (Contributions) Regulations 2001 to extend deadlines for voluntary Class 2 and Class 3 contributions from 31st July 2023 to 5th April 2025, adds tax year 2017-18 to eligible tax years for voluntary contributions, inserts provisions for Class 3 contribution amounts for tax year 2021-22, and updates related headings.

Reason

This amendment reduces regulatory burden by extending deadlines for voluntary contributions and expanding eligible tax years. Britons would be worse off if deleted as it removes flexibility for individuals seeking to protect their benefit entitlements through voluntary National Insurance contributions. The amendment is administratively beneficial and imposes no new restrictions.

keep The Taxes (Base Erosion and Profit Shifting) (Country-by-Country Reporting) (Amendment) Regulations 2023 uksi-2023-752 · 2023
Summary

Amendment to the Taxes (BEPS) (CbCR) Regulations 2016 that removes regulation 3C entirely, omits paragraphs (2)-(4) of regulation 3A, removes notification requirements for Ultimate Parent Entities, and eliminates corresponding cross-references throughout the regulations. The amendment streamlines the CbCR framework by removing outdated transitional provisions and notification obligations.

Reason

The deleted provisions were transitional notification requirements that have served their purpose and are now obsolete. Removing them reduces compliance costs without eliminating the core CbCR reporting mechanism. The substantive reporting requirements under regulation 3A(1) and 3B remain intact, preserving necessary tax transparency for large MNEs while eliminating redundant administrative burdens that applied only during transitional periods now expired.

delete Modifications to the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 uksi-2023-753 · 2023
Summary

These Regulations establish the Responsible Actors Scheme and prohibitions list under the Building Safety Act 2022. The scheme targets residential property developers who built buildings at least 11m high in England between 1992-2022. Developers meeting financial thresholds (£10m+ average operating profits) must join the scheme, enter into Self Remediation Contracts to fix fire safety defects (particularly ACM cladding), or face placement on a prohibitions list restricting planning/building control activities. The regulations create administrative processes for identifying eligible developers, compelling remediation, and enforcing penalties through exclusion from the development process.

Reason

These regulations impose retrospective liability on developers for buildings that were legally constructed under then-existing regulations, creating uncertainty and potentially violating legitimate expectations. The financial thresholds and adjusted accounting definitions create perverse incentives and distortions. The prohibitions list functions as an administrative sanction without proper judicial oversight, restricting legitimate business activity. While fire safety is a legitimate concern, this scheme选的选择性执法和强制性合同安排可能 better addressed through clear property rights, transparent liability assignment at point of sale, or retrospective insurance mechanisms rather than administrative coercion and retrospective cost-shifting.

delete The Safety of Sports Grounds (Designation) (Amendment) (England) (No. 3) Order 2023 uksi-2023-755 · 2023
Summary

This Order amends the Safety of Sports Grounds (Designation) Order 2015 by removing two stadium entries from Schedule 2: Victoria Park (Hartlepool United FC) and Spotland Stadium (Rochdale AFC and Rochdale Hornets Rugby League Club). These removals mean these venues will no longer be subject to the safety certification requirements under the Safety of Sports Grounds Act 1975.

Reason

Removing safety designation from these grounds eliminates an existing regulatory safeguard without clear justification. The Safety of Sports Grounds Act 1975 certification regime exists to protect spectators at larger venues where crowd safety risks are heightened. While these may be smaller clubs, the certification process ensures proper emergency planning, structural safety, and crowd management standards are maintained. Deleting this Order restores the status quo where these venues remain subject to appropriate safety oversight. No evidence is presented that alternative safety mechanisms are in place or that the risk profile of these grounds has fundamentally changed to warrant removal from the designation schedule.

keep The Administration of Estates Act 1925 (Fixed Net Sum) Order 2023 uksi-2023-758 · 2023
Summary

This Order sets the fixed net sum at £322,000 for purposes of the Administration of Estates Act 1925 intestacy rules, specifically the threshold determining a surviving spouse's entitlement. It updates the previous figure to reflect current property values.

Reason

This is a technical, value-neutral administrative provision that simply updates a statutory threshold in line with current property values. Without a defined fixed net sum, estate administration would descend into legal ambiguity and litigation, harming bereaved families. It imposes no economic restrictions, creates no compliance burdens, and does not distort market incentives. The Administration of Estates Act 1925's intestacy framework already exists; this Order merely ensures it functions accurately. Deletion would create genuine harm without any corresponding regulatory cost reduction.