delete Modification of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998
This Order exempts local authorities categorized as 'excellent' by the Secretary of State under the Local Government Act 2003 from various statutory planning and strategy requirements, including: Homelessness Act 2002 duties, Home Energy Conservation Act 1995 reporting, Crime and Disorder Act 1998 youth justice plan requirements, Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000 rights of way improvement plans, Transport Act 2000 local transport plan duties, and Environment Act 1995 air quality action plan duties. Authorities ceasing to be 'excellent' receive transitional protection for 1-2 years.
This Order exemplifies the problem it claims to solve: rather than abolishing unnecessary planning mandates, it creates a two-tier system where 'excellent' authorities can opt out while others remain burdened. The logic of regulatory exemption based on performance categories is inherently paternalistic and creates perverse incentives—authorities may prioritize maintaining their exempt status over actual service delivery. More fundamentally, the Order acknowledges that these statutory planning requirements are so burdensome that even well-performing authorities need relief from them, which raises the question of why such mandates exist at all. The transitional grace periods for authorities losing their 'excellent' status perpetuate regulatory costs without addressing root causes. This represents regulatory tinkering rather than genuine reform—Better Britain should advocate for the abolition of these mandates entirely, not their conditional suspension.