delete Offices disqualifying holders from membership of the National Assembly
This Order designates offices whose holders are disqualified from membership in the National Assembly for Wales, replacing the 2003 version. It covers positions such as judges, civil servants, police, and other public officials whose simultaneous service in the Assembly would create conflicts of interest or compromise institutional separation.
Disqualification regimes limit voter choice by precluding otherwise eligible candidates from serving. Legitimate conflict-of-interest concerns can be addressed through targeted measures like disclosure, recusal, or specific conflict rules rather than blanket disqualification. This Order restricts democratic participation without proven marginal benefit over less restrictive alternatives. The revocation of the 2003 version suggests periodic updating is needed anyway, indicating the underlying framework is suboptimal.