delete REPRESENTATIVE COMMISSIONERS
This Order establishes the River Tweed Commission as a regulatory body for salmon and freshwater fisheries in the Tweed district (spanning the Scotland-England border), prescribing governance structures, fishing methods and equipment restrictions, offences and penalties, valuation and assessment mechanisms for salmon fisheries, powers to remove fish passage obstructions, and catch statistics collection requirements. It consolidates and modernizes previous Tweed fisheries legislation.
This regulation exemplifies the classic public choice problem: a geographically-specific regulatory commission with power to restrict fishing methods, impose assessments, criminalize possession, and control access creates rent-seeking incentives and suppresses market mechanisms for resource allocation. The mandated fishing methods (rod and line, net and coble, bag nets) and prohibitions on others reflect political rather than economic optimization. The valuation roll and fishery assessment system functions as a price control mechanism. While advocates claim ecological necessity, salmon stocks in other jurisdictions have recovered through voluntary conservation agreements and property rights solutions. A market-based system where riparian owners held clearly defined, tradeable fishing rights would internalize conservation incentives without requiring a bureaucratic commission, criminal prohibitions on possession, and political appointment of commissioners representing 'interests of freshwater fishing associations.' The cross-border coordination argument also fails: private contractual arrangements between Scottish and English riparian owners could achieve the same coordination at lower cost.