delete The Investment Trusts and Venture Capital Trusts (Definition of Capital Profits, Gains or Losses) Order 2006
This Order defines 'capital profits, gains or losses' for investment trusts and venture capital trusts for tax purposes under the Finance Acts 1996 and 2002. It establishes three Cases (A, B, C) determining when profits/gains/losses qualify as capital rather than revenue in nature, based on accounting treatment under the Statement of Recommended Practice (SORP) issued by the Association of Investment Trust Companies.
This Order exemplifies regulatory overreach by embedding tax law within private accounting standards — the SORP can be 'modified, amended or revised' without Parliamentary scrutiny, automatically altering tax treatment. It creates unnecessary complexity by distinguishing capital from revenue profits based on which column of an income statement profits are reported in, imposing compliance costs and creating uncertainty. Venture capital trusts themselves represent state intervention in capital allocation; this Order merely adds another layer of complexity to that intervention. The link between a private industry's recommended accounting practice and statutory tax treatment is fundamentally unsound from a rule-of-law perspective.